HomeMy WebLinkAbout8.a. Receive Quotes/Award Contract – Test Well 16, City Project 416 ROSEMOUNTEXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CITY COUNCIL
City Council Meeting: January 7, 2014
AGENDA ITEM: Receive Quotes/Award Contract—Test AGENDA SECTION: Old
Well 16, City Project 416 Business
PREPARED BY: Andrew J. Brotzler, PE, Director of ,ublic AGENDA NO. 3.61.
Works / City Engineer /
ATTACHMENTS: December 17, 2013 City Council
Executive Summary, Resolution, Map, APPROVED BY:
Recommendation Letter, Bid Tabulation,
December 31, 2013 Memorandum Doi
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Motion to Adopt a Resolution Receiving Bids and Awarding
the Contract for Test Well 16, City Project 416 contingent upon recording of the deed to
Outlot G.
ISSUE:
Receive quotes and award contract for the Test Well 16, City Project 416.
BACKGROUND:
At the December 17,2013 Regular City Council meeting the quotes received for the construction of Test
Well 16, City Project 416,were reviewed by Council. From this review the following questions were
noted:
1. Does the well driller need to be licensed?
2. How is the construction of a Test Well different than the construction of a private domestic
well which may be lower priced?
The attached memorandum and exhibits provide information in response to these questions for Council
consideration. In addition, a representative from Bergerson-Caswell, Inc. will be in attendance at the
meeting to respond to further technical questions regarding well construction. A representative from the
Minnesota Department of Health has also been invited to the meeting.
SUMMARY:
Based on the information provided, Staff recommends Council adoption of the attached resolution
receiving the quotes and awarding the contract for the construction of Test Well 16, City Project 416, to
Bergerson-Caswell, Inc.
An option for Council consideration would be the adoption of a motion to reject all quotes and provide
Staff direction on new contractors to request quotes from for the construction of Test Well 16.
G:\ENGPROJ\416\Council Items\20140107 CC Receive Quotes and Award Contract.docx
CITY OF ROSEMOUNT
DAKOTA COUNTY, MINNESOTA
RESOLUTION 2014 —
A RESOLUTION RECEIVING QUOTES
AND AWARDING THE CONTRACT
FOR TEST WELL 16, CITY PROJECT 416
WHEREAS, City Council hereby ratifies action of City Engineer to secure quotes for the Test Well
16, City Project 416,
BE IT RESOLVED,by the City Council of the City of Rosemount,Minnesota, as follows:
1. The quote of Bergerson-Caswell, Inc. of Maple Plain, Minnesota in the amount of
$37,835.00 for the Test Well 16 Project shall be and hereby is accepted.
2. The Mayor and Clerk are hereby authorized and directed to enter into a contract with said
bidder for the construction of said improvements for and on behalf of the City of
Rosemount.
3. Award of the contract is contingent on the determination by the City Administrator that all
necessary rights-of-entry or easements by deed or dedication have been secured for
construction of the improvements.
ADOPTED this 7thday of January, 2014.
William H. Droste,Mayor
ATTEST:
Amy Domeier, City Clerk
WSB
&Ass Engineering • Planning • Environmental • Construction 701 Xenia Avenue South
Suite 300
Minneapolis, MN 55416
Tel: 763-541-4800
Fax: 763-541-1700
Memorandum
To: City Council
City of Rosemount
From: BJBonin PG
Date: December 31, 2013
Re: Rosemount Well 16 Test Well
WSB Project No. 1582-18
There have been some questions regarding the test well for Well 16; specifically why the cost is
greater than a typical domestic well. This memorandum addresses the differences between the
two.
In the November 5, 2013 letter from the DNR to the City of Rosemount,the DNR provided
preliminary approval to construct Well 16 and they strongly encouraged the retention of test well
16 as an observation/monitoring well and indicated that it may be required as part of the
amended appropriation permit. Based on the letter from the DNR test well 16 was designed to be
an observation well. Collection of cuttings and endorsement of the driller's log by a PG or
licensed well driller(varies—not specified yet for this well) are required by the DNR for the
Observation Wells. The DNR often also requires a geophysical log of the Observation Well, but
have not stated so as of yet.
Licensed Driller- The question has been brought up as to why the driller of the test well needs
to be licensed, as licensed drillers are more expensive than unlicensed ones. With the exception
of shallow sand point wells, all wells constructed in Minnesota require some licensed oversight.
If the driller is not licensed,then per Minnesota Well Code the owner(Rosemount) must provide
a licensed manager to supervise the construction of a well.
Cost Comparison—
Attached are a cost and graphical comparison between the test well as designed ($37,835), a
Jordan domestic Well ($31,185) and a domestic well drilled into the drift aquifer($10,470).
There are numerous differences between test well 16 and domestic wells. The more significant
differences that have an impact on construction cost are summarized below.
Depth—Approximate depths: Test well-495 ft, Domestic well in the Jordan formation—425 ft
and Domestic well in the drift— 190 ft.
Minneapolis•St. Cloud
Equal Opportunity Employer
C\Users\ajb AppDam\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Ootlook\RTQJLJOI\Mcmo AB_123 I 13.doc
City Council
December 31, 2013
Page 2
A typical domestic Jordan Sandstone domestic well will be drilled only a few feet into the
sandstone. Test well 16 will be drilled into the St. Lawrence Formation to sample and inspect the
full thickness of the Jordan for the purpose of identifying conditions at the site prior to
constructing the production well and to serve as the observation well the DNR will require as
part of the upcoming appropriations permit amendment for Well 16. A typical domestic well
drilled into the drift will have an even shallower depth.
Casing(s)—Test well and domestic well in the Jordan formation—Double cased 8"X 4".
Typical domestic well in the drift—Single cased 6 inch PVC with screen.
In some geologic settings, a well in this aquifer of this design depth could be constructed with a
single casing, saving money though materials (less casing, less grout). However,the geology at
this site typically only allows about 200 feet of uncased borehole to be constructed before the
mud breaks down and the hole collapses. Domestic Jordan wells in this area would be
constructed as double cased wells.
Development and Test Pumping—Approximately 8 hours development for the test/observation
well and 4 hours for a domestic well. Approximately 4 hours test pumping for the test well and
none for either domestic well.
A typical domestic Jordan Sandstone domestic well would be developed by over-pumping for a
few hours to remove construction debris (from the short length of open hole)while
simultaneously tested for pumping capacity. The domestic well in normally developed or
pumped using air compressor and drill rods as soon as the well has been drilled to final depth,
and normally is the minimum needed to achieve a problem free water well at 15 gpm or less that
will survive a 5-7 year life.
In order to function as the DNR required Observation Well,the well must be developed to
remove construction debris and loose sand from the (full aquifer length) open hole and test
pumped to calculate well efficiency. A typical domestic well would require 1/2 to '/a of the
specified development and test pumping time of a typical test/observation well.
Water Quality Testing—Less water quality testing is needed for a domestic well.
A typical domestic well is required to be tested for coliform, nitrate and arsenic. The test well
will be sampled for a much wider range of chemistry. This is specified in order to determine if
contamination is present at the well site before the municipal well is constructed. In addition,the
well must be pumped to remove at least one well volume of water in order to test the aquifer, not
the well. The hours of development and test pumping are designed to achieve this and are not
done for a domestic well. For clarification: in order to test the water chemistry for a municipal
well on the site of this test well,the test well must be pumped more than a domestic well and
much larger suite of tests are to be done in addition to the arsenic and nitrate tests that are
required for new wells.
C:\Users\nibWppData\LocalUNierosoli\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\ComentOullook\RTQJL1O1\Memo_AB_123113.doc
Project description IZ05e-YVLO)rt+ 1 ) ( f
Aengineering
planning (888) 541-4800 Task description We.bA JQStjvt yttr/ )-ti.
WSBenvironmental Project number I S✓'2 18
mimni■ wsbeng.com 53
&Associates,Inc. construction Designed by Checked by
Date $ 'e-C 13 Page / of
TYP- Ty
T—E$ Welk_ Rock mesa-rc Dry C. Domesix,
Iwo
sue_.'61-
._ .....__.. S;�C= 95
- s
9c0 i I c"Pd c
165 ,Cf-
9 &t00 I
c90 11 I
voo '
$c�s� I ,s ree1�
ts�ce�? , i�=�__�� ze s e;e.�
Tap 4 .Ro c•VC
o A
j 39 !
� .
$�6 _ , I
" �e 10�[
6-00 4,--too� of 6 5arc in
open►hale
-i_ _ - -
. ---",Ai-o 5}. Lewte-OCe St: lawge..tee:
For Ideva-:.iCQ41o«Ρ.
Itao c ! 1,ln L (� n L I T f1,4- [ J
e I-u Il y a�Te5T ° es.1 c -rtrevxlc,()-6.-te • to if c5en ic,n rita�'c
o 6 jvOLCs ce4411 op necti 0 q hours de,Q-ele Meni- ' `t 110a-ts devciapote-va-
p
4 hogs 7 c f f vlO/RAC ° no -te,54- Puny?rn.„, s ho -fest puss cj
Test Well 16 vs Jordan Domestic Well
Test Well Domestic Well-Double Ca
Item No. Item Units Qty Unit Price Total Qty Unit Price Total Difference
1 MOBILIZATION/DEMOBILIZATION LUMP SUM 1 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 1 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $0.00
2 DRILL 8'DIAMETER CASED HOLE LIN FT 190 $45.00 $8,550.00 190 $45.00 $8,550.00 $0.00
3 DRILL 8'NOMINAL DIAMETER OPEN LIN FT 306 $30.00 $9,180.00 236 $30.00 $7,080.00 $2,100.00
HOLE
4 FURNISH&INSTALL COMPLETE 4' LIN FT 397 $15.00 $5,955.00 397 $15.00 $5,955.00 $0.00
DIAMETER INNER CASING
5 FURNISH INSTALL COMPLETE NEAT CU YD 7 $500.00 $3,500.00 7 $500.00 $3,500.00 $0.00
CEMENT GROUT
6 DEVELOPMENT HOUR 8 $225.00 $1,800.00 4 $225.00 $900.00 $900.00
7 FURNISH,INSTALL,AND REMOVE LUMP SUM 1 $1,750.00 $1,750.00 0 $1,750.00 $0.00 $1,750.00
TEST PUMP ,
8 TEST WELL PUMPING HOUR 4 $150.00 $600.00 0 $150.00 $0.00 $600.00
■
9 CHEMICAL ANALYSIS INCLUDING LUMP SUM 1 ' $1,500.00 $1,500.00 1 $200.00 $200.001 $1,300.00
REPORT
(TOTAL II $37,835.0 : I I $6,650.001
Domestic Well in the Drift-6 inch PVC with screen
Item No. Item Units Qty Unit Price Total
1 MOBILIZATION/DEMOBILIZATION LUMP SUM 1 $4,000.00 $4,000.00
2 BORING FOR PVC CASING LIN FT 190 $15.00 $2,850.00
3 6"PVC CASING LIN FT 165 $8.00 $1,320.00
4 FURNISH&INSTALL 4'SCREEN LIN FT 20 $35.00 $700.00
5 FURNISH&INSTALL COMPLETE NEAT CU YD 1 $500.00 $500.00
CEMENT GROUT
6 DEVELOPMENT HOUR 4 $225.00 $900.00
7 FURNISH,INSTALL,AND REMOVE LUMP SUM 0 $0.00 $0.00
TEST PUMP
8 TEST WELL PUMPING HOUR 0 $0.00 $0.00
9 CHEMICAL ANALYSIS INCLUDING LUMP SUM 1 $200.00 $200.00
REPORT
$10,470.001
1031.205, 2013 Minnesota Statutes Page 1 of 3
2013 Minnesota Statutes
103I.205 WELL CONSTRUCTION.
Subdivision 1. Notification required. (a)Except as provided in paragraphs(d)and(e),a person may not
construct a well until a notification of the proposed well on a form prescribed by the commissioner is filed with the
commissioner with the filing fee in section 1031.208,and,when applicable,the person has met the requirements of
paragraph(f).If after filing the well notification an attempt to construct a well is unsuccessful,a new notification is
not required unless the information relating to the successful well has substantially changed.
(b)The property owner,the property owner's agent,or the well contractor where a well is to be located must file
the well notification with the commissioner.
(c)The well notification under this subdivision preempts local permits and notifications,and counties or home
rule charter or statutory cities may not require a permit or notification for wells unless the commissioner has
delegated the permitting or notification authority under section 103I.111.
(d)A person who is an individual that constructs a drive point well on property owned or leased by the
individual for farming or agricultural purposes or as the individual's place of abode must notify the commissioner of
the installation and location of the well.The person must complete the notification form prescribed by the
commissioner and mail it to the commissioner by ten days after the well is completed.A fee may not be charged for
the notification.A person who sells drive point wells at retail must provide buyers with notification forms and
informational materials including requirements regarding wells,their location,construction,and disclosure.The
commissioner must provide the notification forms and informational materials to the sellers.
(e)A person may not construct a monitoring well until a permit is issued by the commissioner for the
construction.If after obtaining a permit an attempt to construct a well is unsuccessful,a new permit is not required as
long as the initial permit is modified to indicate the location of the successful well.
(f)When the operation of a well will require an appropriation permit from the commissioner of natural
resources,a person may not begin construction of the well until the person submits the following information to the
commissioner of natural resources:
(1)the location of the well;
(2)the formation or aquifer that will serve as the water source;
(3)the maximum daily,seasonal,and annual pumpage rates and volumes that will be requested in the
appropriation permit;and
(4)other information requested by the commissioner of natural resources that is necessary to conduct the
preliminary assessment required under section 103G.287,subdivision 1,paragraph(c).
The person may begin construction after receiving preliminary approval from the commissioner of natural resources.
Subd.2. Emergency permit and notification exemptions. The commissioner may adopt rules that modify the
procedures for filing a well notification or well permit if conditions occur that:
(1)endanger the public health and welfare or cause a need to protect the groundwater;or
(2)require the monitoring well contractor,limited well/boring contractor,or well contractor to begin •
constructing a well before obtaining a permit or notification.
Subd.3. Maintenance permit. (a)Except as provided under paragraph(b),a well that is not in use must be
sealed or have a maintenance permit.
(b)If a monitoring well or a dewatering well is not sealed by 14 months after completion of construction,the
owner of the property on which the well is located must obtain and annually renew a maintenance permit from the A'S
commissioner. el(pioca�'wr. ce11 L1eM t ��w
Subd.4. License required. (a)Except as p ovided in paragraph(b),(c),(d),or(e),section 1031.401,
subdivision 2,or section 1031.601,subdivision 2,a person may not drill,construct,repair,or seal a well or boring
unless the person has a well contractor's license in possession.
(b)A person may construct,repair,and seal a monitoring well if the person:
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=103I.205 12/27/2013
103I.205, 2013 Minnesota Statutes Page 2 of 3
(1)is a professional engineer licensed under sections 326.02 to 326.15 in the branches of civil or geological
engineering;
(2)is a hydrologist or hydrogeologist certified by the American Institute of Hydrology;
(3)is a professional geoscientist licensed under sections 326.02 to 326.15;
(4)is a geologist certified by the American Institute of Professional Geologists;or
(5)meets the qualifications established by the commissioner in rule.
A person must register with the commissioner as a monitoring well contractor on forms provided by the
commissioner.
(c)A person may do the following work with a limited well/boring contractor's license in possession.A separate
license is required for each of the six activities:
(1)installing or repairing well screens or pitless units or pitless adaptors and well casings from the pitless
adaptor or pitless unit to the upper termination of the well casing;
(2)constructing,repairing,and sealing drive point wells or dug wells;
(3)installing well pumps or pumping equipment;
(4)sealing wells;
(5)constructing,repairing,or sealing dewatering wells;or
(6)constructing,repairing,or sealing bored geothermal heat exchangers.
(d)A person may construct,repair,and seal an elevator boring with an elevator boring contractor's license.
(e)Notwithstanding other provisions of this chapter requiring a license or registration,a license or registration is
not required for a person who complies with the other provisions of this chapter if the person is:
(1)an individual who constructs a well on land that is owned or leased by the individual and is used by the
individual for farming or agricultural purposes or as the individual's place of abode;or
(2)an individual who performs labor or services for a contractor licensed or registered under the provisions of
this chapter in connection with the construction,sealing,or repair of a well or boring at the direction and under the
personal supervision of a contractor licensed or registered under the provisions of this chapter.
Subd.5. At-grade monitoring wells. At-grade monitoring wells are authorized without variance and may be
installed for the purpose of evaluating groundwater conditions or for use as a leak detection device.An at-grade
monitoring well must be installed in accordance with the rules of the commissioner.The at-grade monitoring wells
must be installed with an impermeable double locking cap approved by the commissioner and must be labeled
monitoring wells.
Subd.6. Distance requirements for sources of contamination. (a)A person may not place,construct,or
install an actual or potential source of contamination any closer to a well than the isolation distances prescribed by
the commissioner by rule unless a variance has been prescribed by rule.
(b)The commissioner shall establish by rule reduced isolation distances for facilities which have safeguards in
accordance with sections 18B.01,subdivision 26,and 18C.005,subdivision 29.
Subd.7. Well identification label required. After a well has been constructed,the person constructing the
well must attach a label to the well showing the unique well number.
Subd.8. Wells on property of another. A person may not construct or have constructed a well for the person's
own use on the property of another until the owner of the property on which the well is to be located and the intended
well user sign a written agreement that identifies which party will be responsible for obtaining all permits or filing
notification,paying applicable fees and for sealing the well.If the property owner refuses to sign the agreement,the
intended well user may,in lieu of a written agreement,state in writing to the commissioner that the well user will be
responsible for obtaining permits,filing notification,paying applicable fees,and sealing the well.Nothing in this
subdivision eliminates the responsibilities of the property owner under this chapter,or allows a person to construct a
well on the property of another without consent or other legal authority.
Subd.9. Report of work. Within 30 days after completion or sealing of a well or boring,the person doing the
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=103I.205 12/27/2013
1031.205,2013 Minnesota Statutes Page 3 of 3
work must submit a verified report to the commissioner containing the information specified by rules adopted
under this chapter.
•
Within 30 days after receiving the report,the commissioner shall send or otherwise provide access to a copy of
the report to the commissioner of natural resources,to the local soil and water conservation district where the well is
located,and to the director of the Minnesota Geological Survey.
History: 1989 c 326 art 3 s 9;1990 c 597 s 28-33; 1991 c 355 s 18-23; 1992 c 507 s 22; 1994 c 557 s 20; 1999
c 153 s 7,8;2005 c 106 s 22,23;2013 c 108 art 12 s 108;2013 c 114 art 4 s 74
https://www.revisor.mn.gov/statutes/?id=103I.205 12/27/2013
Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Minnesota
Division of Ecological and Water Resources
November 5, 2013 1 DEPARTMENT OF
NATURAL RESOURCES,
Andy Brotzler
City of Rosemount
2875 145th St. W
Rosemount, MN 55068
RE: DNR assessment of your proposed well construction,tracking no. 2014-0961
Dear Mr.Brotzler:
The Department of Natural Resources(DNR) received information from you for the construction of a
groundwater appropriation well located in NW%NE%Section 21,T115, R19 Dakota County. Based on
our assessment,we have identified concerns that may need further evaluation. Our assessment
indicates that use of a well at this site at the proposed rate and volume may result in interference
with other water users or negatively impact nearby natural resource features such as a lake,stream,
or wetland.
Preliminary approval to construct a well at this site is granted; however, be advised that in order to
obtain a permit to appropriate water from this well, additional information and tests,at your
expense, may be required. Also be aware that your water appropriation request may be modified,
reduced, or denied based upon site specific information. Please refer to detailed information in the
attached, Well Construction Proposal Assessment for the factors that were assessed and the
additional information that may be required during the water appropriation permit application
process should you decide to drill this well.
This letter does not release you from any other requirements or liability or obligation imposed by
Minnesota Statutes, Federal Law,or local ordinances relating to your proposed project. If you choose
to drill this well,you are responsible for notifying the Department of Health as required by Minnesota
Statutes, chapter 1031.
After you have completed the testing,we would like to see the testing data, including data from the
monitoring wells near well#14, prior to authorizing construction of Supply Well#16.We strongly
encourage retention of this test well as an additional monitoring well and may require it as a
condition of the amended appropriation permit.
Thank you for your cooperation. By seeking preliminary approval for construction of your well you
have received information on the feasibility of this site to meet your needs and can make an
informed decision on whether or not to proceed. If you have any questions, please contact me at
651-259-5790 or Jennie.Skancke @state.mn.us.
Sincerely,
Jennie Skancke
Area Hydrologist
Enclosures: Resource checklist
ec: BJ Bonin,WSB
wwx.nndnr.gov
AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER
%a PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER CONTAINING A MINIMUM OF 10%POST-CONSUMER WASTE
Minnesota
Department of Natural Resources
Well Construction Proposal Assessment, NW%NE% Section 21 T115, R19 Dakota County,Tracking
Number 2014-0961
This preliminary Well Construction Approval is not an appropriation permit.State law requires you to
obtain preliminary approval to drill a well that is required to have a DNR water appropriation permit.A
water appropriation permit from DNR is required for all users withdrawing more than 10,000 gallons of
water per day or 1 million gallons per year. DNR Staff have evaluated your project to determine whether
the proposed appropriation is likely to meet statutory requirements in Minnesota Statutes,section
103G.287.
Checked factors are those that we believe may be impacted by your proposed water use.
n Calcareous fens
❑ Designated trout streams
X Lakes and rivers,wetlands
n Rare Species (Threatened, Endangered, Special Concern), Native Plant Communities (S1-3)
Minnesota Biological Survey Sites of Biodiversity Significance (High, Outstanding)
X Known well interference problems (the nearest is 2 miles)
n Existing water appropriation permits with higher priority as defined in Statute 103G.271
X Publicly owned lands such as DNR Wildlife Management Areas
X Municipal Wellhead Protection Areas, Drinking Water Source Management Areas, Source Water
Protection Area's
n Known groundwater contamination
n Groundwater management areas or areas with declining water levels
If any of the factors above are marked with a checked box,you may be required to install monitoring
well(s), perform aquifer test(s)or provide other information to ascertain anticipated impacts to these
features.This information will be used to evaluate and make a decision on your water appropriation
request.Your water appropriation request may be modified, reduced,or denied based upon site specific
information.
If you choose to drill this well and use more than 10,000 gallons of water per day or 1 million gallons per
year you must submit a water appropriation permit application which can be found
at: http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/waters/watermgmt section/appropriations/permits.html
;. ROSEMOUNT EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
CITY COUNCIL
City Council Meeting: December 17, 2013
- — ---
AGENDA ITEM: Receive Quotes/Award Contract — Test AGENDA SECTION:
Well 16, City Project 416 Consent
PREPARED BY: Phil Olson, PE, Assistant City Enginee AGENDA NO.
ATTACHMENTS: Resolution, Map, Recommendation j
Letter, Bid Tabulation APPROVED BY:
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Motion to Adopt a Resolution Receiving Bids and Awarding
the Contract for Test Well 16, City Project 416 contingent upon recording of the deed to
Outlot G.
ISSUE:
Receive quotes and award contract for the Test Well 16,City Project 416.
BACKGROUND:
On Thursday,December 5,2013,three quotes were received for Test Well 16,City Project 416. After
verification of quotes received,the low quote is Bergerson-Caswell, Inc.,submitting a quote of$37,835.00.
The project includes the construction of the test well and obtaining geological and water quality data.
Costs associated with these improvements will be funded by the City's Water Core Fund.
Test Well 16 will be located on Outlot G of the Bella Vista development. The developer has submitted a
signed Quit Claim Deed for Outlot G. The award of this project is contingent upon recording of the deed
to Outlot G with Dakota County.
SUMMARY:
Staff recommends that Council adopt the attached resolution receiving the bids and awarding the contract
for the construction of Test Well 16,City Project 416 to Bergerson-Caswell,Inc.
G:\ENGPROJ\416\Council Items\20131217 Receive Quotes and Award Contract.docx
T:/GIS/City/Maps/Departmental Maps/Engineering/Chris/Location Map-416
W
128TH
0 ‘Z-
H ST V.V
z
LiJ -7).
MCMENC
CO
POND
li
130TH ST W
, ' *
KEEGAN W
LAKE >1_0
FEGAN
'IS
LAKE
CI 411,
EX
_ <
01
iv 03 ; 1
POND BbNAIREPAT
, 1 ,••
L _ :
/
11/I BIRDS6NG 1-71'
ILI
•'ARE POND Cc
4
1 .,. - ATHENA
9- > 4"
i-
ll /'I BIRDSONG PATCRT.
g /
0 ‘'''1"/ a-
33 0. 1,• . 711W";*) c* .\4
136TH ST W 0 0
/ . 'NY
,T) A"' '13 ,
Z , L.) 0) 15''''' \ (.4*,'<,/, 4.
2. ix
"" ,
* m
0
0
u TRL CONN N7'
1.9
CI ST W co trN SA .„,
-..\/ BELVIDERE IT
t V. > ' `-'---L-11 4'
CT g - i•
C
) 06° 0 —{ \ *,
... uj
*0 C 0
.1 .,
....Z. 140TH ST W --1 E 0
o 0
2 .:z 0 ■'4 , a A,1 1.1 ST W
ce
Birch
BELMONT az
Park
--1 ,------ . ce
UJ
>, CT BIRCH ,Ti.
IV 9
0'0
LU ..MO NT Tr?
Z BELFAST
_..1.1 _ •. _ ...i .- *..-- y..-c :ell
MI MIIIIIIM11111111L4gamm,
I
'' *ROS E MOUNT Well 16
MINNESOTA City Project 416, September 2013 A
A N ■
V
......
A
WSB
&Assoc- engineering-planning-environmental-construction 701 Xenia Avenue South
Suite 300
Minneapolis,MN 55416
Tel: 763-541-4800
Fax: 763-541-1700
December 9,2013
Honorable Mayor and City Council
City of Rosemount
2875 — 145th Street West
Rosemount,MN 55068
Attn: Jean Harrington/Karin Kladar,Public Works
Re: Test Well No. 16 Project
City of Rosemount,MN
WSB Project No. 1582-18
Dear Mayor and Council Members:
Quotes were received for the above-referenced project on Thursday,December 5,2013. Three
quotes were received out of six solicitations. The quotes were checked for mathematical accuracy
and tabulated. Please find enclosed the quote tabulation indicating the low quote as submitted by
Bergerson-Caswell, Inc.of Maple Plain,MN, in the amount of$37,835.00. The Engineer's Estimate
was$50,055.00.00.
We recommend that the City Council consider these quotes and award a contract in the amount of
$37,835.00 to Bergerson-Caswell, Inc.based on the results of the quotes received.
Sincerely,
WSB&Associates,Inc.
217 •
ancy D. igl PE
Senior Project Manager
Enclosures
cc: Tim Berquam, Bergerson-Caswell,Inc.
Andy Brotzler, City of Rosemount
srb
St. Cloud• Minneapolis•St. Paul
Equal Opportunity Employer
wsbeng.com
K:101581-180Wdmi&Conatmaion Adn.inILTR RECALAIDTN-hmttd 20913.doc
QUOTE TABULATION SUMMARY
PROJECT:
Test Well No. 16 Project
OWNER: City of Rosemount, MN
WSB PROJECT NO(S).: 1582-18
QUOTES RECEIVED: Thursday, December 5, 2013, at 12:00 p.m.
Engineer's Estimate Bergerson-Caswell, Keys Well E.H. Renner&
Inc. Drilling Co. Sons, Inc.
Bid Security (5%) N/A N/A N/A N/A
Addendum No. 1 Received N/A X X X
Total Base Quote $50,055.00 $37,835.00 $48,030.00 $49,618.00
I hereby certify that this is a true and correct tabulation of the quotes as received on December 5, 2013.
G je46*&7
Nancy D. Zeigler, PE, Senior Project Manager
DENOTES CORRECTED FIGURE
K:101582-1801AdminlConstruction Admin11582-18 Quote Tab Summary-120513
1
A
INSB , QUOTE TABULATION DETAIL
a4 A.eelN'illlrs,Inc.
Project Name: Test Well No. 16 Project Project No. 1582-18
Client: City of Rosemount, MN I hereby certify that this is an exact reproduction of quotes received.
Quotes Received: Thursday. December 5, 2013, at 12:00 p.m. Engineer: Nancy D. Zeigler, PE, Senior Project Manager
*
DENOTES CORRECTED FIGURE Bidder No.1 Bidder No.2 Bidder No.3
Engineer's Estimate Bergerson-Caswell,Inc. Keys Well Drilling Co. E.H.Renner&Sons,Inc.
Item
No. Item Units Qty Unit Price i Total Unit Price 1 Total Unit Price I Total Unit Price I Total
BASE QUOTE •
1 MOBILIZATION/DEMOBILIZATION LUMP SUM 1 $6,000.00 $6,000.00 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $5,000.00 $12,000.00 $12,000.00
2 DRILL 8"DIAMETER CASED HOLE LIN FT 190 $75.00 $14,250.00 $45.00 $8,550.00 $75.00 $14,250.00 $67.00 $12,730.00
3 DRILL 8"NOMINAL DIAMETER OPEN HOLE LIN FT 306 $40.00 $12,240.00 $30.00 $9,180.00 $40.00 $12,240.00 $30.00 $9,180.00
4 FURNISH&INSTALL COMPLETE 4"DIAMETER INNER LIN FT 397 $20.00 $7,940.00 $15.00 $5,955.00 $20.00 $7,940.00 $14.00 $5,558.00
CASING
5 FURNISH&INSTALL COMPLETE NEAT CEMENT GROUT CU YD 7 $475.00 $3,325.00 $500.00 $3,500.00 $500.00 $3,500.00 $450.00 $3,150.00
6 DEVELOPMENT HOUR 8 $250.00 $2,000.00 $225.00 $1,800.00 $225.00 $1,800.00 $400.00 $3,200.00
7 FURNISH,INSTALL,AND REMOVE TEST PUMP LUMP SUM 1 $2,000.00 $2,000.00 $1,750.00 $1,750.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00
8 TEST WELL PUMPING HOUR 4 $200.00 $800.00 $150.00 $600.00 $150.00 $600.00 $200.00 $800.00
9 JCHEMICAL ANALYSIS INCLUDING REPORT LUMP SUM 1 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00 $1,200.00 $1,200.00 $1,500.00 $1,500.00
TOTAL BASE QUOTE $50,055.00 $37,835.00 $48,030.00 $49,618.00
DECLINED TO SUBMIT:
Steffl Drilling&Pump
Thein Well
Mark J.Traut Wells,Inc.
Page 1 of 1 K:1015814801AdminlConstruction Admin11582-18 Quote Tabulation-120513