Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2.b. Proposals for the Investigation of the former Rosemount Dump SiteAGENDA ITEM: Proposals for the Investigation of the former Rosemount Dump Site AGENDA SECTION: Discussion PREPARED BY: Eric Zweber, AICP; Senior Planner AGENDA NO. ;B. ATTACHMENTS: Consultant RFP Bids APPROVED BY: RECOMMENDED ACTION: None 4 ROSEMOUNT CITY COUNCIL City Council Work Session. February 14, 2007 American Engineering Testing, Inc. $134,467 Braun Intertec Corp. $99,781 Earthtech $80,278 Groundwater Environmental Services, Inc. $147,347 Short Elliot Hendrickson, Inc. $108,004 Terracon $46,738 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ISSUE At the request of the City, Dakota County Environmental Management (DCEM) has issued a request for proposals (RFP) to determine the status of the former Rosemount Dump and explore its opportunity to be redeveloped into business park or light industrial uses The former dump is located on the east side of the Umon Pacific rail line, south and west of South Robert Trail, and north and west of Canada Circle. Six environmental and geotechmcal consultants responded to the RFP and have submitted project proposals and bids. DISCUSSION Six bids have been received in response to the RFP ranging in cost from $46,738 to $147,347. Staff has reviewed the RFPs and has recommended to the DCEM that we interview Braun Intertec and Earthtech American Engineering Testing (AET) has a solid proposal, but seems to be excessive in the amount of work they are proposing. Staff suggested AET as a third candidate if they were to revise there work proposal and bid to match SUMMARY The RFP schedule has the Dakota County Commissioner's authorizing a contract with the selected consultant on February 20, 2007. Staff will provide an update on the progress of the consultant selection at the work session. n AMERICAN ENGINEERING TESTING, INC. CONSULTANTS ENVIRONMENTAL GEOTECHNICAL MATERIALS FORENSICS St. Paul, MN Chanhassen, MN Crosby, MN Duluth, MN International Falls, MN Mankato, MN Marshall, MN Plymouth, MN Rochester, MN Sioux Falls, SD Pierre, SD Rapid City, SD LaCrosse, WI Menomonie, WI Janesville, WI Wausau, WI Palatka, FL Proposal and Statement of Qualifications For Initial Investigation of the Rosemount Dump Site, South Robert Trail, Rosemount, Dakota County, Minnesota Prepared for: January 26, 2007 Dakota County Environmental Management Department 14955 Galaxie Avenue West Apple Valley MN 55124 -8579 AET Proposal Number 3 -07 -006 Prepared by: American Engineering Testing, Inc. 550 Cleveland Ave. North St. Paul, MN 55114 651 659 -9001 www.amengtest.com r. 0 8 D 8 0 2 V Y 8 0 0 0 0 c 0 0 N 8 O O E O g 0 8 0 a O P E 0 2 4 0 LL C CC 00 0 0 °8 0 N O O O O 0 2 0- 0) 0 O O N O n M E O 0 O m 'LTA n en 0 `m U' all C 2 N 00 O N 00 6-0 WW WTTT Ev a0 h g 0- O 0 O H 8 n O N N 8 x 0 gE w E Q U' c V) X N so O yN w w O O L L d 88 UJ 0 C0 0 M s 0 c tc o E u f c °0 E u o e E o 0 c f E w T 5 0 C N �O O U E 0 n w E s a a u i C an 0 O c W N u 0 R 0 Q H 0 ea 0 0 O 0 w 2 L N- 2 0 R 2 0 g B an 0 0 0 0 0 19. Vi N t E n E a o u 2 0 O E 2 ry U 0 U d m E CO 4, 0 0 a 0 N 0 w 0 co 0 M 0 OD O W a 0 m LO 04 0 CI C9 a 0 O CI 0 4', X m O n an N 0 O n O 0 m 09 0 0 O N N rn 8 E 0 0 O 0 0 ce a O n 0 8 m R 8 0 m O 0 2 5 0 co 0 0 5 8 0 CD 0 CO N C E n m 0 3 j o Q 0 c d c a E w Z O 9 O n Et 'c w 1'7,0 E o d H 0 0 0 0 W N 0 MC Q F CO a O r 0 0 00 O 0 0 F mm na S E i ILL U 0 G r e w 2 o c c M c N O n 0 n 0 O N N E 0 0 NO 2 3 E E 0 w 99 QaLLLL2g 0 0 CO O 0 ID 0 LO H 0 0 0 0 n0 0 LL 7 a a a 0 If a E E 2 7 N c .0 0 M 1O 0 0 kfi 0 0 K 0 CO O 0, m 0 n N 0 0 O 01 m N 8 w a O 0 CO N 0 CO 0 0 O h 0 CO H 0 Y Ca 8 K a N a 8 N N Ca 0 a 0 0 0 r 0 0 0 w m y le 08 O O 0 4. N w 0 00 0 .0 0 0 O 90 a H (9 N N N 0 0 0 N 8 E o i 0 c m m E m E C E E o O Q 8 E E o n' o 4 o a E 0 P O T Z C R E c oo c u o m 20 w E o. 0 0 u i W m o omucol g 0 0 0 0 0 E8 m w O 2 w' 0 `o wr 52 2 oI q 00 8 w w co 0, m U' 0 0 g 0 m 8 0 N L N 8 0 w 0 0 8 8 E 3 0 0 0 0 w E n O o co L 8 w 0 0 S 4 m 0 0 C O C 9 82k C i `o_ s!,5 O 0 Q C m a o 8 0 m L CO 8 0 w 0 0 co 0 a 0 N CO 8 8 0 E g N 2 0 8 8 w CO 0 0 0 8 0 N L 0 8 w goo t E U 0. a. 0 88 §3 CO CO m cm W K a b0 0 K `0 0 0 CI CO d 28 00 0 5888 w w 0 0 0 0 N g 8888 0000 000• w w N y N W `l N s o d m d NN y co C4 ID 0 0 N r To O N a 0 0 M CC 0. BRAUN INTERTEC January 26, 2007 Proposal SP -07 -00242 Ms. Cathy Undem, Environmental Specialist Dakota County Environmental Management Department 14955 Galaxie Avenue West Apple Valley, MN 55124 -8579 Dear Ms. Undem: Re: Proposal for Initial Investigation Rosemount Dump Rosemount, Dakota County, Minnesota With this letter Braun Intertec Corporation is forwarding our proposal for the captioned project. We appreciate the opportunity to prepare and present this proposal to you and we would welcome meeting with you and your selection panel to discuss the proposal and answer questions about it. This proposal was prepared in accordance with the Request for Proposal dated January 2, 2007 and Addendum 1, dated January 16, 2007. This proposal will remain valid for a period of not less than 120 days from the date of the proposal. During the period of the proposal evaluation you may direct questions or correspondence as follows: Richard M. Johnston, PG Associate Principal Braun Intertec Corporation 1826 Buerkle Road St. Paul, MN 55110 Braun Intertec has performed over 200 projects for Dakota County in the past 20 years for soils engineering, materials testing and environmental evaluation and we look forward to continuing what we hope is a mutually beneficial working relationship. Sincerely, BRAUN INTERTEC CORPORATION ason J. Kunze Project y Manager Richard M. Johnston, PG Associate Principal Keith Principal *61.8E O-t„ 1 Braun Inlenet Corporation 1826 Buerkle Road Some Paul, MN 55110 Office Phone: 651.487.7050 Office Fax: 65 T .487.1812 Email: rjohnston @braunintertec.com Phone: 651 487.3245 Fox 6514871812 Web brountnienoccom Providing engineering and environmental solutions since 1957 0 N d N N O 0 N O 3 m m—) Extension 006'1 09S Ise $I I $1 1e£ $I N 61L'2 1 0000'S $1 1 000's t k oto'£ I 1 099 $1 II 061 II as $1 N es $1 N e S L N ever $1 Il oa£ $1 N oaz $1 Il m e' L $I IIssL'z $1 N"£s I N ast_ $1 IIsL $1 1009 Si I n 1 S6 ton $1 1 s $1 1 61 $1 1 L7 0 I000's 1 S6 1 O7L $1 s6 1 I £9 $_1 1 £9 1 6/ $1 1S6 $1 1 or 1 9 6 Vi 69 161 $J 1 L7 $J 1 00£ $J Environmental Cost Detail Initial Investigation of the Rosemount Dump Rosemount, Dakota County Minnesota Number of Units 1 oz 1 oe 1 z£ 1 7 t_ 1 9 Z N 091 N twin �rioy limy 1 irioif 1 moy f allw 1 ino 1 moy 1 mo y noy moy 1 .inoy I nog 1 nog moy moy moy moy e6eellw ABP teumssa;otd 1 •AU •uudpabeuetp t oetord ]Principal Scientist 1 Protect Assistant 1 CADD /Graphics Operator I 1 amain 1 lemons L'd Advance Sun/. Eng 1 'F.2 Subtotal 1 Protect Manager/Prin. Inv. I Principal Scientist 1 Staff Scientist 1 Technician IV 1 Project Assistant 1 CADD /Graphics Operator I letotons s'41 IProiect Manager/Prin. Inv. 1 1 tsltuatoS ledlODUd1 ]Staff Scientist 1 ]Technician IV 1ProjectAssistant 1 (CADD /Graphics Operator 1 abeam' l tuewdlnba AiIAltS!SeUI 1F,4 Subtotal 1 uo protect tacKOtr meeting ano site visit wan County /City /MPCA staff S ubcontract Surveyor Draft Work Plan, Site Safety Plan, Contingency Plan. Incorporate Dakota County, Rosemount and MPCA comments and finalize all. Mob /demob, two staff conduct resistivity survey, analyze resistivity data, prepare graphic data displays and written report. Heel I "II 0 N d N N O 0 N O 3 m m—) Environmental Cost Detail Initial Investigation of the Rosemount Dump Rosemount, Dakota County Minnesota N uogenlsng Sep pue "tili°BI 5•d11 N osL N oaz N oon's I szc I l os9'L $I loes'L $I 1 9617 1 my 1 9L4'L 1 II 69E %L II SUoti8AB3X3 9dLI 011 8E II on II 064 $1 1 099' 4 1 II es $1 N ZLE 1 N b£z $1 11009'6 1 I PL9'9 1 I I I slsAlsuy Aso;etogel pue maul Li I 1 oo9'z 1 N OOb'S h oot 1 I l ozL $1 li on $1 log $1 l o*'bt 1 1 OOL 1 sag 1521 1os 041 1 OE 156 $I 1 ObL 1 ea $J 1 £e 1 Lv O 198E 1 LLL 1ooe`1 $1 1 56 1 lab4 1es $1 1 LVo $1 I bL 1 ocZ set $1 I asp $1 1 esL $1 1 oz_ I 173 L_ vz bZ 1 vz Z 1 OZ 1 08 001- OZ44 on 1 goes r goes 1 goes 1 Loss 1 LIMO 1 apse 1 anoy mot; 1 anoy 1 atom 1 Asp As p Asp r anoy 1 ropy 1 may el Ua 1.. too) 1 pea gore 5leoMA 1 )1e9M 1 sOOA' sVNe PCB /Pesticides 1 1 OB01 Pnority Pollutant Metals 1 1 Odo1 F.7 Subtotal 1 •AUI Principal Scientist 1 1 Al uelpluyoey atiealIN 1 uone /sleuelev IIaMI 1Canister TO -15 Analysis 1 1 sllwaad 14 -aas Meter 1 1 aid] 1F.5 Subtotal 1 'AUI vudpaoeuelryPe!OJdl 1 Principal Scientist 1 1Staff Scientist 1 Al uelpluyoel1 ebeelIW Old 14 -aas Meter JO4 AEOX31 1F.6 Subtotal I in F.5 and F.6- Includes environmental samples and QA/QC samples. Prep field staff, mob /demob, 11 days drilling, including 2 days to construct gas wells, monitor gas wells 3 times after drilling. Collect 6 samples by air canister for TO -15 analysis Subcontract with excavator, prep field staff, travel, two days in field. Environmental Cost Detail Initial Investigation of the Rosemount Dump Rosemount, Dakota County Minnesota II luewdolanaG pue uofiellelsul Jelewozaldl 8•d1 11 088 II $Z€' L I 11 Ogre I 118£ $1 II 969'U$ 1 11F.9 (Environmental Reporting 11 1 009'L II 095 118Z£`L 1 II 9Z L 1194£ $I II 0E6'6 II uolleaeda.d dVdG /dva l 04 11 040'£ 11 o48 11 oat. 11 91-£ 11 SE 11 09E17$ 1 11 dviti panoaddy pue laodali leUldl LL'dII 1109L $1 11osz $1 11 89 $1 11 6L $I I I ZSL'L Total 73,897 u 1 96 I Ion $I 1£9 $I 1 6L $J 56 $I 1 on _J 1 I ILV0 $I 1 o 1£e $I I£9 6L $1 196 $1 I at 1 41- Lt+'0 N r r 1 Z£ 1 08 I 08 91. 9L 9?? 08 hour 1 noy I ahoy anoy I ahoy moq m ay moll alliu I 1 noy 1 ino anoy I ahoy ahoy 'nog I moy 1.001 allw 'AU! •updpabeueW loeload lsqueaS ledlouud IProiect Assistant 1 aoletadO solydemp /GCVO leto4gns LL'd 1 'AU] •uudpabeuen loeloadl Principal Scientist 1 IProlect Assistant I ICADD /Graphics Operator I I adeellW lelolgns 0 d IProiect Manager /Prin. Inv. 1 1Principal Scientist 1 Technician IV 1 1Prolect Assistant 1 1 aoleaedO solydeJO /uaVOI IFS Subtotal Project Manager /Prin. Inv. I Technician IV 1 IPiezometer, Installed l abeapwl 1F.8 Subtotal Incorporate County, Rosemount and MPCA comments Into final documents. Incorporate Phase 11 ESA results, redelopment plans and geotechnical recommendations into a RAP /DRAP. Meeting to present results Validate laboratory data, compile tables and s?valu data draft rannrt. draft figures. OA/OC Drilling and staff time are included in G.2 and F.S. This includes time to monitor piezometer construction, develop piezometers and measure water levels. N- 0 N N N CO 0 N O O CL CO --a PROPOSAL for Initial Investigation of the Rosemount Dump Rosemount, Dakota County, Minnesota O co 4- Prepared for. 0 Dakota County Environmental Management Department Apple Valley, Minnesota tocC Prepared by: EarthTech A two International Ltd Company Earth Tech, Inc. 3033 Campus Drive North Suite 290 Minneapolis, MN 55441 January 26, 2007 5 y 6 C 2 31 a R S R R R S g R R F O 2 21 3 R 0 0 0 0 R 8 3 R a' a e 4 R 2R i R Lt R R S R la 3 R R X R Rsag e a R R k R e e 2. =RR? 3211 RR11 O 0 0 O la 3 1 223 b R S Y 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 R 8 R R ea B R a Y O a e !gig 2 2 2 2 0 10 2 3334 1 S In 3 1 1 R R R R 0 R R aaa a s 1 s 8 IX R x 8 c 3 A R 4 R R 0 a R 8 R R R R 8 R 0 R R R R R R 8 S R R R s 8 R R w l 12 a R 8 i 1 L L 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Groundwater L_ 1 Environmental Services, Inc. 1285 Corporate Center Drive Suite 120 Eagan, Minnesota 55121 (800) 735 -1077 Fax (651) 405 -1036 Proposal for the Initial Site Investigation Rosemount Dump Site Rosemount, Minnesota Prepared for: Ms. Cathy Undem Environmental Specialist Dakota County Environmental Management Department 14955 Galaxie Avenue West Apple Valley, Minnesota 55124 -8579 0.4 Prepared by: Groundwater Environmental Services, Inc. 1285 Corporate Center Drive, Suite 120 Eagan, Minnesota 55121 January 26, 2007 1 88 8 g E 8 3 8 g g au" aaaww 5 8 8 8888888 000000 0 o ao000 0 ag8g8383 Zr` aw 8 8 M 88 8 8 888888 asa aaaa4" 8 8 8 8 8 ,8888 888 °88 88aaa8 8 °080 8°oa tnfl fa 00 0 888888 aaaaaa gssgss 8888888 88888.°. a 8 88888 8 33» »a a 8 8„ 88 8 8 sg o '^ee°8 og 8m8883g g gg8g888838 '4, 3» 3333 »I vsss88 »33waa „74 g »s g g g 1 a: =Pfl January 26, 2007 Ms Cathy Undem Environmental Specialist Dakota County Environmental Management Department 14955 Galaxie Avenue West Apple Valley, MN 55124 -8579 Dear Ms. Undem. RE: Dakota County, Minnesota Rosemount Dump SEH No. P- DAKOT0703.00 Short Elliott Hendrickson Inc. (SEH) and Summit Envirosolutions, Inc. (Summit) are pleased to submit this proposal for the initial investigation of the Rosemount Dump in Rosemount, Minnesota. This proposal is in response to your written Request for Proposals (RFP) dated January 2, 2007 and Addendum 1 e- mailed January 16, 2007. SEH and Summit have elected to team on this proposal; combining our expertise, staff and equipment to create the best possible project team for Dakota County. SEH will be the prime consultant and pnmary point of contact for this project. Summit bnngs immediate access to several Geoprobe units, an on -site laboratory, and cutting -edge technology that can efficiently transfer field data to Dakota County's GIS system for responsive "real time" decision making. Al Sunderman will lead this effort and be the County's primary point of contact. He understands the relationship between environmental assessments, response action plans and the County and City's goal of attaining closure for this site through the MPCA VIC Program. Al understands that the ultimate goal is to prepare the site for future development and will manage the project accordingly. We have completed many similar projects that demonstrate our ability to achieve your objectives. We worked with the City of Duluth at the Sargent Creek dump site to investigate, remediate and close the site within a year, culminating in what the MPCA calls "a success story". We will work closely with the County and City to refine the project approach and schedule to ensure a successful project and no interruptions to the City's Public Works Department's responsibilities. This proposal shall remain valid for a period of not less than 120 days from January 26, 2007. Please contact me with any questions. We look forward to continuing working with Dakota County Respectfully submitted, Allen Sunderman, PG Principal Short Elliott Hendrickson, Inc. Allen Sunderman 3535 Vadnais Center Drive St Paul, MN 55110 651.490 2135 (direct) 651.490 2150 (fax) asunderman@sehinc.com 1 weak islssy'uiuJPy 1 c JelsI uIWPy JS I Z I 1s61euy s19 ZL 01 I zZ ueplu40e1 Pleli Z OZ 1 zt {sISoloes Pleli 6 01 0 Z4 OE or 491 Aokoning 9 19 I JO/IeMnq •Js 1 99e 9 1 9 pro ect 1 swops •sse siy Zs I zs I lslluepS oz 9 oc I. 0 lsqu &o$ Js 9 0e I es I Jeeul6u3 •uoJlnu3 m m or 04 1 9 Z1 OP 1 191 1 1eeu16u3'ualnu3'Js 01. 09 Je6euery 3e(ad co m m Z 01 06 9 O6 ledioupd r r r 6 z1 0 c L l0 0. 01 0 d a O O 0. l0 O o i R co y V s_z a L r N c E g Q1 Q O E m G O 0 W ae r r 0 0 >a c o W E W N O O U R ..J O Y tC 0 0 0 N 0 0 u 0. m cc N m E 0 O 0 9 V •0 0 0 0 O a 0 U 0 a 0 0 x To 0 0 0 3 0 m C 0. 0) m co h o. o. m 0 a m Tr 0 C m u .0 N a C .0 0 0 U' N 0 `0 2 M O a W m Y c O O O 0 m 0 2 (0 (0 0 a C 5 0 Q 0 re o LL O e 0 a u N e a e s at o W 0 o w M 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N 0) N 0 N 0 rs 0 0 00) 0 2 M f9 0 C .0 vi w w04 w r Jwy w 0 o N i m O 0 0 O m 0 0 .0 10 0 u d -I n a 3 0 m y a o 0 d a H e 0 n 3 d U 0 -7,2,01" 1- 0 w c of Q 3 LL e m n 0 c_ i 4 u p n w o m w v m° `m 9 m m n u era. m 2 m `m m u c r q ai 0 u o 0 Fi w b p a_ no uJ o Z m m 5Kh O 00 co n Q of r N d an OO r- co CO r N N Hourly Billing Rate Task Description twice' Site Review Proposal for Environmental Services Rosemount Dump Dakota County Environmental Management Department and City of Rosemount Presented by January 26, 2007 cl PH I `w 3 1 f ICSIMEIZEI 00 SC CO 999s 4 00 )62 4 E I OC 00624 411 :Description Evaluate Data, Prepare Final Investigation Report and Prepare acme Action Plan 00 SZ 4 009LE5 0D 096 so oas'9 4 I E 8 807 00 E 46 738 00 E 55 645 00 rasped algae telol pargraorW 1 a j I s 455 uo 1 00016 4 0000 0 00889 E 00 0000 4 00 900 4 00 060 4 00006 4 0009 s 0000 1 s 00 UV s 00 0 4 00004 4 00 000 9 of I DE 9049 W6 ,4 009010 SI 00000 E 0030 S 00006 YI 00 z08'I Y 00 011 0 00050 4 0005 4 00 006 4 5 a 200 00 3 300 00 1$ I E f 4 55 5 Igo1 ewil I 0004 000 1 0009 00 8 00 60 m 00 09 I-I 1 1 4$l 7 1 4052 E 00909 4 0009 4 Do Oa) 4 00540 4 00 00 0 00001 S 00 46 S I s 130001 0040 S 00 011 4 E 10000 4 50 00 1$ z6000I S 1 ,341 00 f 1,601 ride =10", s Too 001 f ee0ao s 285 0015 108001 s .l s feast is 1 1 S 1,120 00 1 1 3,41080 s l 339001E 220001 s 375001 J S e- u Other Cortraemra dohnei)uoagn3, 1 far „his) 1 fro, since{ ViNAS, Drafting TecSnldan 4 2500015 660 Is 5,254001I -1 �r on 00 0 11 1 '41 r'r 11000 1,01500 1 455 00 E 2,100 00 4 4,96000 4 28500 3 5,1880014 23000 I 55400 f 2,240.00 5 5.08000 1,90000 3 1,23400 E 22000 5 846.00 ri AdmInatnuve 1 1 00 P ugalu408 001903la3 �S MOD 1 oo 1 00 0 0008 00 9 6 00 k" 00 9 00 02 1 00 8 1 lsllePa44 t Seaford 00 Z 1 00 9l 004 10600500 lrfwd 009 ooz 00 90 00 ledlaLpd welad 009 004 Pawaq SV papaary ey 1 pawed se 6 papaad sV PaPeahl ay 0 pap00N sy w Mr.=.1 a or wpaell w 1 0 0a ss4 00 054 00 OM 00 564 00 0E4 000014 00 404 40000 Op 006'045 aq rvr a° xm'DOt w na CMCe110101 00 s94 00 000'24 00 On 00 0044 23 you 00 Total Optional Task 1 �*H r1, Total Cost Proposal Total Cost Proposal with Optional Task I TASK Description Prepare Comprehensive Work Plan I I ravel to Ate (me per visdl Prepare Comprehensive Work Plan (including 5ne Safety Plan and Environmental Contingency Plan) Protect Coordination and Meetings Miac Expenses and Equipment Total Task 2 1 end .,J#T Test Pits, Soil Borings and Probes, and Geplechnical E Travel to site (memo) Test pit and sod probe/boring oversight Proled Coordination Vehicle Trip Charge fel 00 mdeMday)I$/day) SniI SampS:o 10t Groundwater Sampling Kn Water level Indicator Pholmomzel :on Detector (Elday) pH Temp Cone meter Muc Expenses and Equipment Gb0MTory Analyse Sao Water and 038(Eallmate) Excavation Subooniradat(Eal :male) Druling Subcontractor Env ironmental an6;, Geolebhnlcal (EStimelel r me110Site )firs per visit) Evaluate Data, Prepare Final Investigation Repot and Prepare RAP and/or CRAP Protect Coordination ad Meetings Mlac Expenses and Equipment (4) 4cellea10500I 0leu0 Ys 'mg I Test pit and soil probe/baring 00055 :50 rest Evaluation Proled Coordination Veneta Trip Charge (4100 miles/day) ($/day) So'Sampling Kit Mien Expenses and Equipment LaMVlory Maiyals Geohchnl04 IESOmate) Do0in 6nboonlracd0r E8v4omfiental and Geplechnlcal(Eatimale)%t cl PH I `w 3 1 f