Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2.a. Parks Dedication Requirements and Dedication Fees EXECUTIVE SUMMARY City Council Work Session: April 10, 2017 AGENDA ITEM: Parks Dedication Requirements and Dedication Fees AGENDA SECTION: Discussion PREPARED BY: Dan Schultz, Parks and Recreation Director AGENDA NO. 2.a. ATTACHMENTS: Survey of Parks Dedication Requirements, Land Value Market Study and Metropolitan Council Housing Information APPROVED BY: LJM RECOMMENDED ACTION: None, discussion only.   ISSUE The Parks and Recreation Commission recently reviewed and subsequently recommended that the City adjust our parks dedication collection methods and residential dedication fees. The review was done in part because of a complaint we received from a developer who was bringing forward a high density development project. The developer felt it was unfair to charge a one bedroom apartment the same parks dedication as a four bedroom home. The topic of collecting parks dedication was discussed by the Commission at several meetings in 2016 and 2017. It was also discussed by the City Council at the October 10, 2016 work session. Staff has reviewed our parks dedication methods, plus the methods of many other local communities and is recommending that we adjust our parks dedication collection methods to have different collection requirements for low, medium and high density developments. The dedication requirements would then be tied to the type of density and how many people are expected to live in each unit based on housing information provided by the Metropolitan Council. One item that was also discussed by the Parks and Recreation Commission and the City Council was the fact that parks dedication land values were last studied in 2010. Both the Commission and City Council recommended that we hire a consultant to prepare a Value Market Study to help us set our parks dedication fees because they are based on land values. The Land Value Market Study showed that there is a clear difference in land prices for varying types of density levels. With that information, staff is recommending that we set a per acre parks dedication fee for low, medium and high density developments. Staff is recommending that the methods of collection and parks dedication fees listed below be discussed. There is a recommendation on how to move forward from both staff and the Parks and Recreation Commission.   Current Method and Fees     density                      units/acre    dedication per unit   land value per acre  cash dedication/unit      All densities            N/A               .04 acres per unit    $85,000    $3,400    Staff’s Proposed Method and Fees      density                  units/acre    dedication per unit   land value per acre  cash dedication/unit      Low density      1 to 5 units/acre             .04 acres per unit    $85,000    $3,400  Med density    6 to 12 units/acre           .03 acres per unit   $95,000    $2,850  High density     12 to 30 units/acre         .02 acres per unit  $125,000    $2,500    Parks Commission Proposed Method and Fees      density                  units/acre    dedication per unit   land value per acre  cash dedication/unit      Low density      1 to 5 units/acre             .04 acres per unit    $85,000    $3,400  Med density    6 to 12 units/acre           .03 acres per unit   $105,000    $3,150  High density     12 to 30 units/acre         .02 acres per unit  $145,000    $2,900    Listed below are scenarios that show what the dedication would be for a 60 unit development in all three of the density categories as proposed by staff.   60 Unit Development Scenarios    density            units    per unit fee     total cash dedication   or    Land in‐lieu of cash  Est. new residents   Low density      60  $3,400    $204,000  or   2.4 acres    180  Med density    60         $2,850    $171,000  or   1.8 acres     130  High density     60        $2,500    $150,000  or   1.2 acres     94  BACKGROUND Parks Dedication Collection - Minnesota State statutes provide municipalities the opportunity to collect a portion of a subdivision for public purposes. Listed below is the state statute language pertaining to the dedication of land in a subdivision and also the language about the nexus of between the impact of the development and the required dedication. Subd. 2b.Dedication. (a) The regulations may require that a reasonable portion of the buildable land, as defined by municipal ordinance, of any proposed subdivision be dedicated to the public or preserved for public use as streets, roads, sewers, electric, gas, and water facilities, storm water drainage and holding areas or ponds and similar utilities and improvements, parks, recreational facilities as defined in section 471.191, playgrounds, trails, wetlands, or open space. The requirement must be imposed by ordinance or under the procedures established in section 462.353, subdivision 4a. (b) If a municipality adopts the ordinance or proceeds under section 462.353, subdivision 4a, as required by paragraph (a), the municipality must adopt a capital improvement budget and have a parks and open space plan or have a parks, trails, and open space component in its comprehensive plan subject to the terms and conditions in this paragraph and paragraphs (c) to (i). (c) The municipality may choose to accept a cash fee as set by ordinance from the applicant for some or all of the new lots created in the subdivision, based on the average fair market value of the unplatted land for which park fees have not already been paid that is, no later than at the time of final approval or under the city's adopted comprehensive plan, to be served by municipal sanitary sewer and water service or community septic and private well as authorized by state law. For purposes of redevelopment on developed land, the municipality may choose to accept a cash fee based on fair market value of the land no later than the time of final approval. "Fair market value" means the value of the land as determined by the municipality annually based on tax valuation or other relevant data. If the municipality's calculation of valuation is objected to by the applicant, then the value shall be as negotiated between the municipality and the applicant, or based on the market value as determined by the municipality based on an independent appraisal of land in a same or similar land use category. (d) In establishing the portion to be dedicated or preserved or the cash fee, the regulations shall give due consideration to the open space, recreational, or common areas and facilities open to the public that the applicant proposes to reserve for the subdivision. (e) The municipality must reasonably determine that it will need to acquire that portion of land for the purposes stated in this subdivision as a result of approval of the subdivision. (f) Cash payments received must be placed by the municipality in a special fund to be used only for the purposes for which the money was obtained. (g) Cash payments received must be used only for the acquisition and development or improvement of parks, recreational facilities, playgrounds, trails, wetlands, or open space based on the approved park systems plan. Cash payments must not be used for ongoing operation or maintenance of parks, recreational facilities, playgrounds, trails, wetlands, or open space. (h) The municipality must not deny the approval of a subdivision based solely on an inadequate supply of parks, open spaces, trails, or recreational facilities within the municipality. (i) Previously subdivided property from which a park dedication has been received, being resubdivided with the same number of lots, is exempt from park dedication requirements. If, as a result of resubdividing the property, the number of lots is increased, then the park dedication or per-lot cash fee must apply only to the net increase of lots. Subd. 2c.Nexus. (a) There must be an essential nexus between the fees or dedication imposed under subdivision 2b and the municipal purpose sought to be achieved by the fee or dedication. The fee or dedication must bear a rough proportionality to the need created by the proposed subdivision or development. (b) If a municipality is given written notice of a dispute over a proposed fee in lieu of dedication before the municipality's final decision on an application, a municipality must not condition the approval of any proposed subdivision or development on an agreement to waive the right to challenge the validity of a fee in lieu of dedication. (c) An application may proceed as if the fee had been paid, pending a decision on the appeal of a dispute over a proposed fee in lieu of dedication, if (1) the person aggrieved by the fee puts the municipality on written notice of a dispute over a proposed fee in lieu of dedication, (2) prior to the municipality's final decision on the application, the fee in lieu of dedication is deposited in escrow, and (3) the person aggrieved by the fee appeals under section 462.361, within 60 days of the approval of the application. If such an appeal is not filed by the deadline, or if the person aggrieved by the fee does not prevail on the appeal, then the funds paid into escrow must be transferred to the municipality. The City of Rosemount’s current parks dedication requirement for residential development presumes that a reasonable amount of land has been dedicated for parks if a sub-divider dedicates one twenty-fifth 1/25 of an acre for each dwelling unit of the proposed subdivision (acres to be dedicated = 0.04 x number of dwelling units). If the City chooses to accept cash instead of land dedication to satisfy the parks dedication requirements, .04 is multiplied by a per acre value set by the City Council. One issue with the current dedication requirement is that all residential units are dedicating the same amount of land/cash even though the residential unit might vary greatly in size and potential impact to the parks system. For example, a single family home with four bedrooms is dedicating the same amount of land as a one bedroom apartment. Staff have reviewed the parks dedication methods of several other cities and included some examples in a survey that is included in the packet. The examples that staff has provided show that some cities use a sliding scale of percentages for land to be dedicated based on density, some base the dedication on how many people will reside in a specific dwelling type and some such as Rosemount and Savage, have a flat method of collecting the dedication because it is the same no matter the type of housing unit or density of the development. At the bottom of the survey, you will see a proposed adjustment to our current collection method. Land Value Market Study - The City of Rosemount recently hired Evergreen Land Services to conduct a Land Value Market Study to assist the City with setting our parks dedication fees. At the City’s request, Evergreen has gathered land sales information within the City of Rosemount and surrounding communities and prepared a market study analysis. The market study is based on sales that are considered market qualified. Transactions that appeared to be between related parties, older contract for deeds that were finalized, or sales influenced by atypical market motivations were excluded from this study. SUMMARY Staff is recommending that the City Council review and discuss the parks dedication collection methods and parks dedication fees. Staff is recommending that the City Council consider directing staff to change how the City collects parks dedication and that our parks dedication fees are adjusted. Parks Dedication Requirements     City      Rosemount (current):     1/25 of an acre per unit (.04 acres of land per unit)     Lakeville:     Low density     Less than 3.0                 12 %    Med density    3.0 to 9.0                  14 %    High density    More than 9.0     17 %       Farmington:     0 ‐ 2.5                 units per acre                   11 %    2.6 ‐ 5.0              units per acre       12 %    5.1 ‐ 7.5              units per acre       13 %   7.6 ‐ 10.0           units per acre            14 %    10.1 ‐ 12.5         units per acre         15 %    12.6 ‐ 16.0         units per acre        16 %        For each 2.5 units over 16/acre add .25%     Eagan     0 – 1.9                units per acre                   8 %    1.9 – 3.5             units per acre                  10 %    3.5 – 5.9             units per acre                  12 %   6.0 ‐ 10.0           units per acre            14 %    10+                     units per acre         add .5% for each unit over 10      Eagan also has a separate trail dedication requirement      Inver Grove Heights    Percentage based on type of development     R‐1 & R‐2        10%  R‐3A, R‐3B & R‐3D      20%  R‐3C     30%     Savage     10% of the net developable land     Apple Valley       0.00955 acre per resident      Detached SF                  3.2 persons per dwelling unit  Attached SF                   2.1 persons per dwelling unit  Multiple family             1.7 persons per dwelling unit    Burnsville   The dedication formula for residential land shall be based on the  national standard of providing ten (10) acres of parks and open  spaces per one thousand (1,000) population and residential  subdivisions shall be computed on the proposed number of  dwelling units in a project and the average population for  dwelling unit type as established by the metropolitan council.  Shakopee     1 acre of land for every 75 people     Single family                 3.0 people   Duplex/twin                 3.0 people   Apt or townhouse       1.0 person per bedroom    Chanhassen     1 acre of land for every 75 people     Single family                  3.5 people   Two‐family dwelling    3.0 people   Apt or townhouse        1.0 person per bedroom    Rosemount (proposed)      Low density     1 to 5 units per acre           .04 acres per unit    Med density    6 to 12 units per acre         .03 acres per unit    High density    12 to 30 units per acre       .02 acres per unit    2015 Annual Population Estimates Rosemount city, Dakota County, Minnesota Households:8,095 Occupancy Rate:97.66% Population in Households:22,962 Population in Group Quarters: 80 Total Population:23,042 Average Household Size:2.837 Single‐family‐detached:5,248 Townhomes:1,428 Duplex, 3‐, 4‐plex units:76 Multifamily units:920 Manufactured homes: 181 Other (boats, RVs, etc. as shelter):0 Housing Total: 7,853 Housing Stock  April 1, 2010  331 37 8 86 ‐16 0 0 0 Permitted and  built since 2010  Other changes  since 2010  Housing Stock  April 1, 2015  Occupancy  Rate 2015  Persons Per  Household  Population in  2015   Occupied with  Households  99.17% 94.42% 99.50% 93.46% Single‐family‐detached: Townhomes: Duplex, 3‐, 4‐plex units: Multifamily units: Manufactured homes: Other: 5,517 1,383 84 940 171 Households:8,095 3.006 3.006 2.182 1.577 3.245 2.368 16,585 4,157 183 1,482 555 0 In Households:22,962 In Group Qtrs:80 Total Population:23,042 Counted only if  occupied The Metropolitan Council's Annual Estimates account for housing stock changes since April 1, 2010. These include housing units permitted and other  changes. Other changes are due to demolitions, building conversions (units added or lost), city boundary changes (units annexed in or out), and other  changes reported by city and township staff. We assume that 95% of single‐family detached units, 90% of townhome/duplex/triplex/quadplex units,  and 85% of multifamily units permitted in 2014 were completed and occupiable by April 1, 2015; the remainder are occupiable in the future and will  count toward next year's estimates (for April 1, 2016). Manufactured homes are counted each year from Metropolitan Council surveys of manufactured home park operators and local governments. Other  housing (boats, RVs, etc. used as housing) comes from the most recent American Community Survey estimates. Each housing type has a specifically estimated occupancy rate and average household size. These data come from the most recent Community  Survey estimates, decennial census data from the U.S. Census Bureau, and the U.S. Postal Service (for occupancy rates only). For more detail, please  see the full methodology, available online from http://www.metrocouncil.org/populationestimates .  Definitions: A household is a group of people (or one person alone) occupying a housing unit.                        The number of occupied housing units and the number of households are equivalent.                       Population in Group Quarters (or institutional housing) is counted separately through an annual Metropolitan Council survey. Housing Stock  April 1, 2015  Housing Total: 8,289 8,289 5,563 1,465 84 1,006 171 0 Housing Total:8,289 100.00% 5,563 1,465 84 1,006 171 00 5/6/2016Metropolitan Council MARKET STUDY SUMMARY OF LAND SALES FOR CITY OF ROSEMOUNT DATE OF MARKET STUDY: November, 2016 PREPARED FOR: CITY OF ROSEMOUNT DEPARTMENT OF PARKS and RECREATION 13885 SOUTH ROBERT TRAIL ROSEMOUNT, MN 55068 PREPARED BY: EVERGREEN LAND SERVICES 4131 OLD SIBLEY MEMORIAL HIGHWAY, SUITE 201 EAGAN, MN 55122 1 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services Evergreen Land Services Company 4131 Old Sibley Memorial Highway, Suite 201 Eagan, MN 55122 Tel: (651) 882-0200 December 15, 2016 City of Rosemount Attn: Mr. Dan Schultz 13885 South Robert Trail Rosemount, MN 55068 RE: City of Rosemount Market Study Dear Mr. Schultz It is our understanding that Parks and Recreation Department is looking for land sales within the City of Rosemount and surrounding communities for setting the parks dedication fees. The purpose of this report is to provide market sales to use for consideration as data for parcels experiencing acquisitions for the future dedication fees. At your request we have gathered land sales within the City of Rosemount and surrounding communities and prepared a market study analysis. The market study is based on sales that are considered market qualified. Several of the sales have not been verified by Evergreen Land Services at this time. Transactions that appeared to be between related parties, or older contract for deeds that were finalized, or sales influenced by atypical market motivations, were excluded from this study. A good portion of the study area is currently high density residential, commercial and agricultural land. The majority of the sales used already had city sewer and water in place. This was taken into consideration when determining values. Typically land will sell for much less without utilities in place, but will sell higher than areas where no future extension of city sewer and water is planned. With this being said, until a detailed appraisal is conducted on each individual property affected, the values could vary from the data provided. Our conclusions from our market study are as follows: 2 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services Land Values for Future Commercial Use in Study Area ½ to 5 acre parcels $6.00 to $10.00 per square foot 5 to 20 acre parcels $4.50 to $7.00 per square foot Land Values for Future Industrial Use in Study Area 1 to 10 acre parcels $3.00 to $4.00 per square foot 10 to 25 acre parcels $1.50 to $3.00 per square foot Land Values for Low, Medium and High Density Residential Development Land Use in Study Area 5 to 20 acre parcels Low to Medium $50,000 to $85,000 per acre 1 to 20 acre parcels Medium to High $85,000 to $125,000 per acre 1 to 20 acre parcels High $125,00 to $250,000 per acre No party, other than the client, may use or rely upon this report without the prior written authorization. If you have any questions regarding the information contained in this report, please call or email me. Sincerely, Matthew S. Storm SR/WA 651-882-0200 Matthews@elsco.net 3 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services TABLE OF CONTENTS ITEM PAGE NO. LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL ........................................................................... 1-2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ...................................................................................... 3 COMMERCIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP ............................................... 4 COMMERCIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS SUMMARY .................................... 5 INDUSTRIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP .................................................. 6 INDUSTRIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS SUMMARY ....................................... 7 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP .................... 8 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT LAND SALES & LISTINGS SUMMARY ......... 9 ADDENDA ........................................................................................................ 10 COMMERCIAL SALES ................................................................................ 11-25 INDUSTRIAL SALES ................................................................................... 26-36 RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT LAND SALES .......................................... 37-57 4 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services Listing 7 Comp 2 Comp 1 COMMERCIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP Listing 5 Comp 4 Listing 6 Comp 3 Subject Area 5 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS SUMMARY Average Price Per SF for Commercial Sales/Listings = $6.90/sf Sale Property Sales Size Acres/ Sales Price Per # Address Date & Square Feet Price SF Sales 1 14755 Robert Trail South, Rosemount, MN 03/2016 1.57 ac or 63,389 sf $ 325,000 $ 4.75 2 16150 Pilot Knob Road, Lakeville, MN 09/2014 23.17 ac or 1,009,285 sf $6,168,357 $ 6.11 3 15265 Carrousel Way, Rosemount, MN 10/2015 0.87 ac or 37,897 sf $ 280,000 $ 7.39 4 21060 Keswick Loop, Lakeville, MN 8/2015 3.50 ac or 152,460 sf $1,150,000 $ 7.54 Listings 5 XXXX 151st Street, Rosemount Current Listing 2.434 ac or 106,025 sf $ 600,000 $ 5.66 6 XXXX County Road 42 Rosemount, MN Current Listing 0.94 ac or 40,946 sf $ 407,940 $ 9.36 7 XXXX Dodd Blvd, Lakeville, MN Current Listing 15.5 ac or 675,180 sf $5,063,850 $ 7.50 6 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services Comp 1 INDUSTRIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP Subject Area Listing 4 Listing 5 Comp 2 Comp 3 7 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND SALES & LISTINGS SUMMARY Average Price Per SF for Industrial Sales/Listings = $2.80/sf Sale Property Sales Size Acres/ Sales Price Per # Address Date & Square Feet Price SF Sales 1 8190 215th Street W., Lakeville, MN 11/2014 5.07 ac or 220,849 sf $ 662,547 $ 3.00 2 XXX Briggs Drive, Inver Grove Heights, MN 02/2014 1.82 ac or 79,279 sf $ 200,000 $ 2.52 3 6055 150th St W Apple Valley, MN 10/2015 21.58 ac or 940,024 sf $2,172,000 $ 2.31 Listings 4 XXX Hwy 3, Rosemount, MN Current Listing 21.33 ac or 929,135 sf $3,720,000 $ 4.00 5 XXX Robert Trail S., Rosemount, MN Current Listing 19.30 ac or 840,702 sf $1,800,000 $ 2.14 8 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services RESIDENTIAL DEV. LAND SALES & LISTINGS MAP Comp 1 Comp 2 Subject Area Comp 3 Comp 4 Comp 5 Comp 6 Comp 7 Listing 8 Listing 9 Listing 10 9 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW, MEDIUM and HIGH DENSITY RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT LAND SALES & LISTING SUMMARY *Low Density **Medium Density ***High Density Average Price Per Acre and SF for Sales/Listings = 110,834/acre or $2.47/sf Sale Property Sales Size Acres/ Sales Price Per # Address Date & Square Feet Price Acre/SF Sales 1* XXX 65th St E Inver Grove Heights, MN 04/2016 5.37 ac or 233,917 sf $ 775,000 $ 144,320 or $3.31 2* 20XXX Kaiser Way Lakeville, MN 05/2014 16.45 ac or 712,206 sf $ 785,000 $ 47,720 or $1.09 3* 19770 Kenwood Trail, Lakeville, MN 03/2014 14.55 ac or 633,798 sf $ 844,520 $ 58,043 or $1.33 4* 4865 Pilot Knob Road, Eagan, MN 12/2014 3.90 ac or 169,884 sf $ 334,900 $ 85,871 or $1.97 5* XXXX 70th Street W., Inver Grove Heights, MN 10/2015 14.77 ac or 643,381 sf $ 1,065,000 $ 72,106 or $1.66 6** 3400 Upper 149th Street, Rosemount, MN 08/2016 1.487 ac or 64,773 sf $200,000 $134,498 or $3.08 7** XXXX Connemara Trail, Rosemount, MN 07/2015 8.81 ac or 383,763 sf $558,000 $ 63,337 or $1.45 Listings 8* XXXX Brooklyn Ln, Eagan, MN Current Listing 3.97 ac or 172,933 sf $ 314,987 $ 79,341 $1.82 9** 17600 Pilot Knob Road, Lakeville, MN Current Listing 10.00 ac or 435,600 sf $ 680,000 $ 68,000 $1.56 10*** XXXX Dodd Blvd, Lakeville, MN Current Listing 14.26 ac or 621,165 sf $5,063,850 $355,108 or $7.50 10 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services ADDENDA 11 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALES 12 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 1 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 14755 S. Robert Trail City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C-1 Convenience Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 34-64593-01-010 Legal Description: Lots 1 and 2, Block 1, Evenson First Addition, Dakota County, Minnesota. Lengthy description in file. Size Acres or Square Feet: 1.57 acres or 68,389 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Rosemount Port Authority Grantee(s): JsQuad, LLC Date of Sale: March, 2016 Confirmed With: eCRV, Dakota County and County Assessor Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed armslength Sale Price: $ 325,000.00 Per Acre & SF: $ 207,006 or $4.75 DESCRIPTION - Located in the northwest quadrant of County 42 and Highway 3 in the City of Rosemount - Rectangular in shape - High visibility site on U.S. Highway 3, located in a commercial area. - Frontage on Hwy 3 - Developed into a Culver’s restaurant. (See aerial view on following page) 13 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 1 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 14 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 2 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 16150 Pilot Knob Road City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant Commercial Lot Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: PUD, Planned Unit Development and guided to Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 22-71320-01-010, 22-71320-01-020 and 22-71320-00-010 Legal Description: Lots 1 and 2, Outlot A, Dakota County Size Acres or Square Feet: 23.17 acres or 1,009,285 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): SBF Development Corp. Grantee(s): Hy-Vee Inc. Date of Sale: September, 2014 Confirmed With: eCRV and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed armslength Sale Price: $ 6,168,357 Per Acre & SF: $ 266,221 or $6.11 DESCRIPTION - The site is located on the southeast corner of County Road 46 (or 160th Street) and County Road 31 (Pilot Knob Rd). Good traffic counts in this area. - Mostly rectangular in shape - Site was developed for Hy-Vee grocery store, gas station and future retail space. (See aerial view on following page) 15 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 2 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 2 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 16 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 3 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 15265 Carrousel Way City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant Commercial Property Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C4, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 34-71176-01-030 Legal Description: Lot 3, Block 1, South Rose Park Third Addition, Dakota County, Minnesota Size Acres or Square Feet: .87 acres or 37,897 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Rosemount Properties, LLC Grantee(s): TJEI Investments, LLC Date of Sale: October, 2015 Confirmed With: eCRV and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Arms length Sale Price: $ 280,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 321,836 or $7.39 DESCRIPTION - Irregular in shape - Access on Carrousel Way - Mainly level - Visibility from Chippendale Ave. West (See aerial view on following page) 17 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 3 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 18 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 4 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 21060 Keswick Loop City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant Commercial Land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C-3, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 22-03500-03-011 Legal Description: Lengthy description in file Size Acres or Square Feet: 3.50 acres or 152,460 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): The Mary Louise Scherer Living Trust Grantee(s): Lakeville Hospitality , LLC Date of Sale: August, 2015 Confirmed With: eCRV and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Armslength Sale Price: $ 1,150,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 328,571 or $7.54 DESCRIPTION - Rectangular in shape - Located on the SE corner Hwy 70 (210th Street) and Keswick Loop, close to Hwy 35 - Site developed for a hotel (See aerial view on following page) 19 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND SALE NO. 4 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 20 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 5 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX 151st Street City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant Commercial land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C-4, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: Part of PID 34-47501-01-020 Legal Description: Part of Lot 2, Block 1, McNamara 2nd Addition, Dakota County, Minnesota Size Acres or Square Feet: 2.434 acres or 106,025 SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Merchants Bank National Association Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Confirmed With: Multiple Listings Services, Listing Agent and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: List Price: $ 600,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 246,507 or $5.66 DESCRIPTION - List property is excess land from the bank that is located at 15055 Chippendale Av. - According to the listing agent, approximately 1.4 acres is developable. Remainder is lowland area. - Access would likely be from 151st Street. - Outline on aerial photo below is an estimation. (See aerial view on following page) 21 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 5 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 22 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 6 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX County Rd 42 City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C3 and C4, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: No PID at this time. Legal Description: Rosewood Center Lot 2, Block 1 Size Acres or Square Feet: 0.94 acres or 40,946 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Confirmed With: MN Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Sale Price: $ 407,940 Per Acre & SF: $ 433,978 or $9.96 DESCRIPTION - Lot is on County road 42 - Mainly flat (See aerial view on following page) 23 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 6 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 24 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 7 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX Dodd Blvd City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C3, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 22-17052-00-030 Legal Description: Cherry Highlands 3rd , Outlot C Size Acres or Square Feet: 15.5 acres or 675,180 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Confirmed With: Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Sale Price: $ 5,063,850 Per Acre & SF: $ 326,700 or $7.50 DESCRIPTION - On the corner of Dodd Blvd and Cedar Ave. - Irregular in shape. - Mostly level. (See aerial view on following page) 25 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMMERCIAL LAND LISTING NO. 7 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 26 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND SALES 27 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 1 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 8190 215th Street W. City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant Land Highest & Best Use: Industrial development Zoning: I-1, Light Industrial PIN/ Geo Code: 22-10375-01-012 Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Acorn Tappe Addition, Dakota County, Minnesota. Remaining long legal retained in file Size Acres or Square Feet: 5.07 acres or 220,849 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): American Bank of St. Paul Grantee(s): County Road 70, LLC Date of Sale: November, 2014 Confirmed With: MN Dept. of Revenue, Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Arms length Sale Price: $ 662,547 Per Acre & SF: $ 130,680 or $3.00 DESCRIPTION - Rectangular in Shape - Industrial area - Access from County Road 70 (See aerial view on following page) 28 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 1 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 29 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 2 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXX Briggs Drive City/Township & County: Inver Grove Hts. Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Industrial development Zoning: Industrial PIN/ Geo Code: 20-76952-01-010 Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Total Construction Third Addition, Dakota County, MN, together with a non-exclusive driveway easement created in Doc. No. 1315561 Size Acres or Square Feet: 1.82 acres or 79,279 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Wilfred K. Krech Grantee(s): Zelen’s Holding, LLC Date of Sale: January, 2014 Confirmed With: MN Dept. of Revenue and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Arms length Sale Price: $ 200,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 109,890 or $2.52 DESCRIPTION -Irregular in shape -Industrial area -Near Highway 52 (See aerial view on following page) 30 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 2 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 31 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 3 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 6055 150th St. W. City/Township & County: Apple Valley Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Industrial development Zoning: Industrial PIN/ Geo Code: 01-40970-00-010 Legal Description: East Half of the SW Quarter, Sec 26, T 115, R 20 Remaining lengthy legal in file. Size Acres or Square Feet: 21.58 ac or 940,025 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): HBP Property Holdings, LLC Grantee(s): Karamella, LLC Date of Sale: October, 2015 Confirmed With: CRV, Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Arms length Sale Price: $ 2,172,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 100,649 or $2.31 DESCRIPTION - Rectangular in shape - Mostly level - Access from 147th St. W (See aerial view on following page) 32 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND SALE NO. 3 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 33 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND LISTING NO. 4 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXX Hwy 3 City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota County Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Commercial/Industrial Development land Zoning: Industrial, guided to Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 34-03210-70-025 Legal Description: Sec. 32, Twn. 115, R. 19, Dakota County, Minnesota. Lengthy legal in file. Size Acres or Square Feet: 21.33 acres or 929,135 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Dovestone, LLC Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Current Listing Confirmed With: Colliers International is listing the property Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Current Listing List Price: $ 3,720,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 174,402 or $4.00 DESCRIPTION - Near rectangular in shape - Access off of Hwy 46 (See aerial view on following page) 34 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND LISTING NO. 4 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 35 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE INDUSTRIAL LAND LISTING NO. 5 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXX Robert Trail S. City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota County Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Industrial development Zoning: Industrial PIN/ Geo Code: 34-03210-70-019 & 34-03210-70-024 Legal Description: Sec. 32, Twn. 115, R. 19, Dakota County, Minnesota Size Acres or Square Feet: 19.30 acres or 840,702 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Car Nav Five Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Current Listing Confirmed With: CRBE Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Current Listing List Price: $ 1,800,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 93,264 or $2.14 DESCRIPTION - Lot is mostly open and level, but does have some difficult terrain in the very northeast portion of the property. - List property consists of two tax parcels. - Property is marketed by CRBE and described as industrial land. (See aerial view on following page) 36 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services INDUSTRIAL LAND LISTING NO. 5 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 37 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT LAND SALES 38 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE LOW - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 1 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXX 65th Street E. City/Township & County: Inver Grove Hts. Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Low - Density Residential Dev. Zoning: R1 Low - Density PIN/ Geo Code: 20-36500-09-150 Legal Description: Inver Grove Factory Add. Lots 1 thru 10 & 16 thru 30. Size Acres or Square Feet: 5.37 acres or 233,917 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): Eternity Homes, LLC Date of Sale: April, 2016 Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: armslength transaction Sale Price: $ 775,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 144,320 or $3.31 DESCRIPTION - Irregular shape - Mostly level - Near Concord Blvd (See aerial view on following page) 39 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW – DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 1 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 40 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 2 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 20XXX Kaiser Way City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Residential development Zoning: R-1,Low Density PIN/ Geo Code: 22-71501-00-010 Legal Description: St. Frances Woods 8th Add. Outlot A N/E ¼ SW ¼, Section 25-114-21 Size Acres or Square Feet: 16.45 ac or 712,206 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): Date of Sale: May, 2014 Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Armslength Sale Price: $ 785,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 47,720 or $1.09 DESCRIPTION - Sale property is fairly level with some wetlands - Close to Hwy 35 (See aerial view on following page) 41 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW – DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 2 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 42 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 3 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 19770 Kenwood Trail City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Farmstead Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R1 Low Density PIN/ Geo Code: 22-44900-05-282, 22-44900-00-020, 22-44900-04-160, 22- 11500-05-181 & 22-44900-04-040 Legal Description: Lot 28, Block 5, Lenihans Lots Antlers Park, part Lots F (Antlers Park) & G, lying N. of line commencing on SW line Lot G 552 ft SE of NW corner E.& parrellel N. line 460.9 ft, remaining long legal retained in file Size Acres or Square Feet: 14.55± acres or 633,798± sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Richard E. & Nancy L. Cross Trust & Cross Nurseries, Inc. Grantee(s): Ryan Contracting Date of Sale: March, 2014 Confirmed With: MLS and County information Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed Armslength Sale Price: $ 844,520 Per Acre & SF: $ 58,043 or $1.33 DESCRIPTION - Sale located along NE side of Kenwood Trail and W. side of Ipava Avenue - Railroad tracks across Kenwood trail and school located on other side of Ipava Avenue - Existing buildings on property to be removed by developer (See aerial view on following page) 43 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 3 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 44 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 4 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 4865 Pilot Knob Rd City/Township & County: Eagan Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R-1, Low Density PIN/ Geo Code: 10-03400-29-050 Legal Description: Lot 1, Block 1, Parkview Golf Club & E. ½ of the SW ¼, except the N. 361.60 feet of the W. 760 feet thereof, Sec.34, Township 27, Range 23 Size Acres or Square Feet: 3.90 acres or 169,884 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Frank Lehman Grantee(s): Norton Homes, LLC Date of Sale: December, 2014 Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen land Services Conditions of Sale: armslength transaction Sale Price: $ 334,900 Per Acre & SF: $85,871 or $1.997 DESCRIPTION - Mostly open and level - Former acreage homesite - Close to Pilot Knob Rd (See aerial view on following page) 45 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 4 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 46 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 5 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX 70th Street W City/Township & County: Inver Grove Heights Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R-1, Low Density PIN/ Geo Code: 20-000700-26-012 Legal Description: Section 7, Twn 27, R 22, Lengthy legal on file. Size Acres or Square Feet: 14.77 acres or 643,381 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Bernice Messerich Trust Grantee(s): Peterandrea Investments, LLC Date of Sale: October, 2014 Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed armslength transaction Sale Price: $ 1,065,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 72,106 or $1.66 DESCRIPTION - Located in Inver Grove Heights - Generally level and open land (See aerial view on following page) 47 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 5 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 48 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 6 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 3400 Upper 149th Street City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R3 – Medium Density PIN/ Geo Code: 34-628580-10-020 Legal Description: Rahns 9th Addition, Block 2, Lot 1 Size Acres or Square Feet: 1.487 acres or 64,773 SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): St. Croix Home Buyers, Inc Date of Sale: August, 2016 Confirmed With: MLS Information Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed armslength transaction Sale Price: $ 200,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 134,498 or $3.08 DESCRIPTION - Mostly open and level - Close to County Rd 42 & downtown Rosemount (See aerial view on following page) 49 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services MEDIUM - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 6 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 50 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND SALE NO. 7 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX Connemara Trail City/Township & County: Rosemount Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R3 – Medium Density PIN/ Geo Code: 34-58607-00-010 Legal Description: Outlot A, Preswick Place, 8th Addition, Sec. 22, Twn 115, R 19 Size Acres or Square Feet: 8.81 acres or 383,763 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Arcon Development, Inc Grantee(s): KRB Development, LLC Date of Sale: July, 2015 Confirmed With: CRV and Dakota County Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Assumed armslength transaction Sale Price: $ 558,000 Per Acre & SF: $ 63,337 or $1.45 DESCRIPTION - Irregular in shape - Mostly level and open - Close to Hwy 3 (See aerial view on following page) 51 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services MEDIUM - DENSITY LAND SALE NO. 7 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 52 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND LISTING NO. 8 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX Brooklyn Ln City/Township & County: Eagan Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev. Zoning: R-1, Low Density PIN/ Geo Code: 10-03600-81-030 Legal Description: Long legal retained in file Size Acres or Square Feet: 3.97 acres SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Current Listing Confirmed With: MLS Information Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Current Listing List Price: $ 314,987 Per Acre & SF: $79,341 or $1.82 DESCRIPTION - Close to Hwy 3 - Mostly level and some trees (See aerial view on following page) 53 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services LOW DENSITY LAND LISTING NO. 8 AERIAL FROM WASHINGTON COUNTY GIS 54 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEVELOPMENT LAND LISTING NO. 9 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: 17600 Pilot Knob Rd City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Single Family Residential Dev Zoning: RM3 – Medium Density PIN/ Geo Code: 22-01200-50-013 Legal Description: Section 12, Township 114, Range 20, long legal retained in file Size Acres or Square Feet: 10.0 acres or 435,600 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Gaylen R. Olson Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Current listing Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Current listing Sale Price: $680,000 Per acre & SF: $68,000 or $1.56 DESCRIPTION - Rectangle in shape - Close to a creek - Close to Pilot Knob Rd - Some trees and mostly level (See aerial view on following page) 55 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services MEDIUM DENSITY LAND LISTING NO. 9 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS 56 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services COMPARABLE DEV. LAND LISTING NO. 10 PROPROPERTYPERTY INFORMATION Property Address: XXXX Dodd Blvd City/Township & County: Lakeville Dakota Present Use at Time of Sale: Vacant land Highest & Best Use: Commercial development Zoning: C3, General Commercial PIN/ Geo Code: 22-17052-00-030 Legal Description: Cherry Highlands 3rd , Outlot C Size Acres or Square Feet: 15.5 acres or 675,180 sf SALES INFORMATION Grantor(s): Paul O. Johnson, Bault State Bank of Fari Grantee(s): Date of Sale: Current Listing Confirmed With: MLS Confirmed By: Evergreen Land Services Conditions of Sale: Current Listing Sale Price: $ 5,063,850 Per Acre & SF: $ 326,700 or $7.50 DESCRIPTION - On the corner of Dodd Blvd and Cedar Ave. - Irregular in shape. - Mostly level. - Listing is advertised per MLS as potential uses as ie: apartments, town houses, and senior housing. Property is zoned for commercial. (See aerial view on following page) 57 ___________________________________________________________________________ evergreen Land Services HIGH - DENSITY LAND LISTING NO. 10 AERIAL FROM DAKOTA COUNTY GIS