HomeMy WebLinkAbout6. Grief Brothers Planning Commission Appeal0 f 0 P U Box 510
�y O NIVI WMI S1 W
osent tounRUSEMUUNT. MINNFSUTA 55061
G t 612-- 423-4411
TO: CITY COUNCIL
FROM: MICHAEL WOZNIAK, CITY PLANNER
DATE: JULY 28, 1988
SUBJ: AUGUST 2, 1988 REGULAR MEETING REVIEW- ITEM 6
6. PUBLIC HEARING- GREIF BROTHER PLANNING COMMISSION APPEAL
At their June 21st meeting the Planning Commission denied a building permit
request of Greif Bros. Corporation for a 15,000 square foot addition (80' x 180%
attached to back wall) to that company's existing building at 2750 145th Street
West. The denial of this building permit was based upon the aesthetic
appearance of the exterior of the proposed addition; specifically the use of
metal siding to cover 100% of the exterior wall surfaces. Greif Bros. Corporation
has chosen to appeal this decision of the Planning Commission to the City
Council as provided in Zoning Ordinance.
Copies of a site plan, building elevations, floor plan, and landscaping plan will be
available for Commission review at the meeting
In initially reviewing the proposal for the addition on Tune 7th the Planning
Commission suggested that the use of materials which are comparable to the
existing building (concrete block faced with brick) would be preferable to the
proposed 100% metal sided addition. After the proposal being tabled at the June
7th meeting the applicant proposed the use of landscaping to enhance the
appearnace of the addition (see landscape plan). The Planning Commission did
not find the proposed landscape treatment as providing the addition with an
acceptable appearance and proceeded to deny the permit at their June 21st
meeting.
During this process representatives of Greif Bros. Corporation consistently argued
that the Steel framed metal sided construction would provide a more energy
efficient structure which would require less maintenance. The applicant has also
argued that the appearance of the addition is appropriate for an industrial
building and that the addition will not be located in a highly visible area.
Throughout the review process Community Development Staff has noted that the
potential exists for further industrial park development to occur immeadiately to
the south of the proposed addition. In the past Staff has been directed by the
Commission to promote the use of masonry or combinations of building materials
to avoid all metal structures.
It is important to note that there are no building code or zoning ordinance
requirements which would preclude the metal -sided exterior of the addition. The
basis of the Planning Commission decision is that allowing 100% metal sided
construction could set a precedent for building construction elsewhere in the I-
Park District which could have a larger impact on the overall appearance of the
City and also effect property values and the desire to invest in quality,
attractive buildings.
Staff will further review and answer any questions Council might have at the
meeting.
AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION
STATE OF MINNESOTA ) SS
County of Dakota )
NANCY J. GUSTAFSON, being duly sworn, on oath says that she is an authorized agent and
employee of the publisher of the newspaper known as Dakota County Tribune, and hos full knowledge
of the facts which are stated below:
PUBLIC NOTICE
'"PIM NIAAW
(A) The newspaper has complied with all of the requirements constituting qualification as a legal
d the Gyty at RoaanoRosemountTWHOM us MAY CONCERN:
The Afar Caused of
hold
as provided by hUnnesato Statute 331 A.02,331 A.07 and other applicable laws, as amended.
will a Public an Tuesday,
August 2,1999 intbeCamdi d the
N,
City HA2M idtb Stied Wait, ft
sts:09 m.,araooutbere 't
of Ilk k is taceiw dye
(B) The printed - �-
aammeats at
Zoning Appeal of Greff Blue. C61POVEVAIK
2M 145th Street Wed, in
�;
regard to-danial at
a o"
re pomdt for a V 000 sre fad a&
dNbon to as existing building on the grounds
of unsatisfactory aesthode busbuset. The
property in quo dada► is bgally described as
Actor's Subdivb3an No. 1: Pact of Lot a
bbtl east of goad R/W, west of Hoe
parallel to and 777.9 feet south of the North
which is attached was cut from the columns of sold newspaper, and was printed and published once
line of the southeast Quarter of Section 30,
Township its, Raeye 1l.
Such
persons as re to be board with
reference to the above Nem vdu be beard at
fr •for suave weeks; it was
this medirt
Dated dtk 19M da d Juiy, =.
STEPHAN J>LI{
S
Adminktr*;;/— eek
fast published on Thursday, the day of
City of Rosemount
Dakota County, iiftonImots
m
14 0 and was thereafter printed and published on every Thursday to and including
Thursday, the day of ,19 ;
and printed below is a copy of the lower case alphabet from A to Z, both inclusive, which is hereby
acknowledged as being the site and kind of type used in the composition and publication of the notice:
a bcdetghi jklmnopgrstuvwxyz
iJ
BY: �h L . "cf
TITLE: Seaetary"tolthe btiah�r
Subscribed and sworn to before me this S_ day of
U
Noisy Fublie
asp vats. �.,.:e:,•�
..z, CAROL,!, ,t.
{AVE13K
D
NofARYPIMLIC MINA
DAKOTA C)LI3. Y9My C'Wnm. Ess. L'e.
Affidavit Posted Hearing Notice
Greif Bros. Zoning Appeal
STATE OFMINNESO'I)A
COUNTY OF DAKOTA)ss
CITY OF ROSEMOUNT
Stephan Jilk, being first duly sworn, deposes and says:
P.O BOX 510
2875 -145TH ST. W.
ROSEMOUNT. MINNESOTA 55068
612-423-4411
I am a United States citizen and the duly qualified Clerk of the
City of Rosemount, Minnesota.
On July 12, 1988, acting on behalf of the said City, I posted at
the City Hall, 2875 145th Street West, copies of the attached
notice of a public , hearing for the request for zoning appeal
building permit denial as requested by Greif Bros.
There is delivery service by United States Mail between the place
of mailing and the places so addressed.
s
�0(--
Stepho Jilk—
Administrator/Cler
City of Rosemount
Dakota County, Minnesota
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 12th day of July, 1988.
Nota)y Public%'
1,_�•, c. t.%`I
�' r .'J NO1M,i °l r d'ar "c;ii1TA 5,
+' VA,WIAC(YUNTY
NTY cchtl EXPIALS JUNE 11. 1532
3 P
E
PO BOX 510
2875-145 111 S1 w
�r�{,L
ROSEMOUNT. MINNESOTA 5501Ai
�,osey i oLt n 612 -423-4411
Public Notice
TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
The City Council of the City of Rosemount will hold a Public
Hearing on Tuesday, August 2, 1988 in the Council Chambers of
the City Hall, 2875 145th Street West, beginning at 8:00 p.m., or
soon there after. The purpose of this hearing is to receive
comments on the Zoning Appeal of Greif Bros. Corporation, 2750
145th Street West, in regard to denial of a building permit for a
15,000 square foot addition to an existing building on the grounds
of unsatisfactory aesthetic treatment. The property in question
is legally described as folidws:
Auditor's Subdivision No. 1: Part of Lot 65 lying east
of railroad R/W, west of line parallel to and 777.8 feet
south of the North line of the Southeast Quarter of
Section 29, Township 115, Range 19.
Such persons as desire to be heard with reference to the above
item will be heard at this meeting.
Dated this 12th day of July, 1988.
Step) n Jilk, Ad lstrator/Clerk
City of Rosemou t
Dakota County, Minnesota