HomeMy WebLinkAbout6. Siemers Pole Building Denial Appeal • •
p fl E3C1X 51p
��� � 2R75-145TN .'',T W
� � �+q ` y�q/ ROSEMDUNT. MINNFS(?Tt! 55l�f8
� OJG��If��VIf�� � � 61?--473-QQtf�
TO: CITY COUNCIL
�te� �a.
FROM: MICNAEL WOZNIAK, C[TY FLANNER
DATE: NOVEMBER 9, 1988
SUBJ: NOVEMBER 15, 2988 - REGULAR MEETING REVIEWS
PUBLIC HEARING - CRAIG AND JULIE SIEMERS ZONING APPEAL
The p�trpose of this �ubtic hearing is recieve comments and evaluate the denial t�y the
Planning Commission of a Building Permit Application for an accessory building to ije
located on a 10 acre pareel zoned for agricultural use on Akron Avenue. Included with
this review is a copy of the application, a site plan, and a certi€icate af svrvey showing
the boundaries af the parcel.
The proposed buitding is of pole construction and is metal sided with a mefal rc�af �aith a
}�oured conerete floor. the dimensions of the proposed building are 4U' x fi0' (2�Q0 sq.
ft.). City policy requires Chat any pro�osed accessory building over 3000 sq. ft. in size to
. be located in an Agricutture bistrict which is not to be used for agricultur�l pur{�ases
must be approved by the Planning Commission b�fare a Building Permit may be issued.
The Pla�ning Commission reviewed this petmit a}�ptication at their Qctober i$th meeting
and denied the applieation on the basis that the proposed use of the accessary buildin� i's
not permiEted in the Agriculture District.
The basis for the Planning Commission's deeision is that the Siemexs are proposing tMis
accessory buitding to house three trucks (semi-tractor/trailers) which they own and lease
to a private company. The Planning Commission has interpreted this use as that of a
C�mmercial Trucking Operation which is 'not allowed in the Agriculture District.
If the Siemers happened to be truckers and were simpty �lanning tc� store a singie truck
which they personally operated then it could be viewed as a horae occupation and allnwed
in the Agriculture District. However, the storage of trucks w�hich which are leasca wc�uld
mean that drivers would have to come to the �remises to pick u� and dr�p off the trticks
and �robabiy would be �arking their persona} vehieles on the �rc�prerty. Also nothing says
that if this nse af the property were allowed that it woutd not be expanded ta inclucie
a�lditional trucks. Among the issues of eoncern is that Akron Avenue is noE an improved
raad and cauld be negatively impact�d by additional truck traf[ic. It is the Pl�nning
Commissions belief that this proposed stvrage of trucks should be treated nc� treatec3 no
different than other commercial trucking operations such as Walbon Trucking and not be
allowed to be conducted out of a pole barn on a parc�el zoned for Agrieulture.
It shvuld be noted also that it is the policy of the City not to allow the constructi�n of
an aecessory structure on a property prior to the contruction of a principat structure
(home). The Siemers have suggested that they do intend to build a home on the }�roperty '
at some point in the future. If an accessory building were tv be approveci the �ppr�c�ai
would have to be eontingent u�on a htiilding Uermit having been issued for � princi�,�1
structure.
I wt�uld suggcst that the City C'ot�ncil upl�trld thc Fl�rnning Contmission decision and clrny
ap{�r�val of this bailding permit request hecause the pro{�osed use of the structure is nc�t
permitted in the Agriculture District.
�ui�ulnu utE�nRTMENT �,
� � City of Rasemount H
, � ' I►PPCICATIOt�R Qi�i(.pi� pERMIT AND CERTIFIG� OF �CUP CY v
�,
a'' $truCttme USed dS ��'. ��/-/'') Ddte �Q f C; � �'
VAL.taA1TON: $ �
-- �_..__ --�
�..r
� PERMISSION IS HEREBY 6RMfiED ��a3' �,r�y� o
----- QWNER� ` -��..�PrSADDRESS %�� Q 1 ��� ' •
� �,,,i,..l C�I2�..,"� /Yj � PHONE �W 1�ISGv"��s��
---� CONTRACTOR ADDRESS
t'N[1NE �f
10 cerry out the work a�ecified in thi� pern�it an tlie Poilnwing desctfhod nr�e+rty u�►cm thn exRr�s�
condition that seid per�c►ne and their Agences� employeee erxi Morkmen, in euch Mork dorre, shali confor� !n
ell respecta to the provisiorrrs of tire 8uiiding Code. ihia permit �aay be revaked at �ny tl�e u�r�m tlm
vioiation af eny of the provisiw�s of said code.
.:a�� an° a.�a tz�rac�t � nn�
SIREET NUMBER STREEt NAME LOi BL(3GK ADbItION UR PARCE}. N
�
1Q��rv�� �e . ,�'s�v� �-- �� �-j;
�
fRON? WIDTH SI�E IENGiH NELGIIi / OF StORIES Sq. F't. EXtERIUR MItTERIAl Sit3E YARb SEtBACK
SIDE OF S?REET BEtWEEN NtNAt STREETS
E3lDG. PMT. FEE
�_
PII�N CNECK FEE � DETAILS �t RE?{ARKS
'.�,r: .. �_
SUI2GNARGE
METRO S.A.C.
..�.r.
RSMT. SEWER
RSNT. WAIER ."..—,....—�
fliMER
--__ , �
tOfAL
SKETCW UF BUILDING
n ice e e ac e encea
�- ?he tu�ersigned herehy IRAIfP.3 npplic�tion fnr � �crmi�
to do conrstructicm a�r herei� speciFied, r�yreeinr� ko
ck� e work in stric »ec�rdanee with the lk�l)ciinq
c ..
. ,.
-�-- � �
��w . .re:cs �c e a r re�• inn SI[;NAT E
ARE iltEftE PRUT�CiIVE £EJVENANtS?
ey •tention:, • .
rtin D"'es Lauriers • , �et 1 of 2
k a Central LTd. • ' � '
450 South Robert Trail , �
sem��•nt, MN 55058
_ DELMAR H. SCHWANZ ' -�
� uNo sunvErons.rNc. . '
n.or.+«.e u�e«�..,.a rn.aut.o����«a. - - -
14750 SOUTH ROBERT TRAII. ROSEMOUNT.MINNESOTA 56des d12/423-1769 '
�-., -
. SURYEYOR'S CERTt�tCATE ,
�
. PROPOSED DESCRIPTIONS, N1ILTflN SW)iNSON PROPERTY:
PARCEL A •
, The south 328.09 feet of the north 394.09 feet of the West Half of the
• Northeast Quarter oF Section 22, Township 115, Range 19, Dakota Gounty, '
Minnesota.
Containing 10.00 acres. � � ��
Subject to all easements of record. '
P1�RCEL B '
The south 328.16 feet of the north 722.25 feet of the West Hal€ of the
Northeast Quarter of Seation 22, Township 115, Range I9, Dakota County,
Minnesota. . • •�- •• - • .
� Gontaininq 10.00 acres.
Subject to all easements of record. ' ',
.� .
_.._T .
Note: No property corners set as of 09-06-$8.
�
, �
�by certity that this turvsy�p���,or ropoN wa� � •
r`ep�red by m�or undsr my dtrect tupervl*tan and '
�at 1�m a duly ReQi�terod land Surysyor u�der _
�e taw�of tM Stst�of Mtnnssota, �� � ,
Mlma�N.3ctrw�nt
��#ed na_n�..AQ ' Minn�sota RplatMk�rt Mo.5836 , ' .
..__._.
i ;..,,,. . . � , .- ��. .,
,//
+ ' • ^ � ..V . . • . . ... .
.. vt i�� � .� . . . . � . .. . . .'�,p' .
`.r:, . . , . . . . . . . . .
�
. . . . \�. . � � � . . ..
� .. . . . I � � � �
'
� t��L�� �U X�i d
� �' �y F't� Sl C1.2
- Ucxx.t I s
, �,��QY�'Cr ��e L
' S��I.o S�� rc�F
i �
, `
f
; �
; M i n�-��P�
. � �vYI�-�t� �1���--
f
f 3 �,v,� ,�K�z� �aC f, 6,�'�e...
, _ _ � _ � _ ` __ � pt/P_r !'�a d -�rs
�- ; ' � �q�v� � l��r`
�7��'Q-'� �
J Q��
�
�
(��i I � ��- �C� �� ��J>�«�����
��,�z ,,�
L S�`r(�-l�� C�
� . _ &r..z.�.����-z�
�,. ,��
�� �
-.,. 4�°'0+ �p Q.k. ,
�S�'
� --�
�� � 3��(=►
��'����� . . . . . . -�- - - - _ _ .. .
. �� �
� ��I��a
/ N i � i�,
--- ,' / , `L
� � • �
,
• �
�
�
/��C� f�r�e�
• ..i ..�i
, �M'MI�INM10 9'N��NO• 0��� Wt�Q •�
l�1�7��/�1 c, ��6��LT�619'N •�w.«�w•wro«nw�.���
;f �i��'���r�"[�`�� ,.. r �, HOua w�4wnY w.t D�q•IbiY+4+ro s w.11•W ,
, � � ��.SZi Il � Ow WqN+�Cni ia��W A�r Nvue�o�w tV Mnd.�A - •^•,.
� � � � •' . . ��r No!u io�w�V•Awm M»uVt Hn+�s Aau��� �. �
i •
� � �i�^N��(�D 9Ni7' f1tAO�c �`•�
. ---T: a� �._ `.0 '
. I � � � -� -� '�
. C4���� / . . � � � �
. . �^'/. .. • . . �� f
� ' � ��t�'f�..r . . . . � � . . . . � .' .
. . � � • . ' •�Y . � .. � .
� 1j,�. 1:' ' ' � . � � I .
_ `�1.C)n: • � _ �
. .. . . 'A'.Go' . . . _ . ' . , . . � . .
' �
( , fl
. . . . �` , . . . . �' . _
� � � ' • ' � .
4. v y
� � • �� `
� •.
- R1 �
s�y�tr ��•�s �
. N` . � . . �� �. .
. . � .. . ; � . . � � . . . . � : .
�
. . o ` \ . ' . . . I �e � ,•-�+,,,'
�
�1 °�` _ ... . � v
'A �j • . . � � 4
n1 � . � � .
� y
� N
, � ►p
�
. I � fl
�
� �
I �
��
�
��T. �/.:371�'� ? . st+.X,lS�Ef/►' • �.
�... +.
; � . •�/radi•- __ j
, W r .__ �..: _.
6� �
. . �. � 5.��.,d o�.a, �
. � � ��,�d� �� _,
.
.�.sr.Es.6n ,t
,�... •9sYZ�i-. �
� ��t�
� � g gay�b' o+v•oi �
• . !Y �.�.�a�b'�/ �9
. �� � .�St,F.f.6BN I; , --.
. � ,.'�.. , � j>�i'sb�f0'S ��tY'Ltt/ •• � � � �.
/vni.4G9�x3 � �
' - �j 1�.8N s�r+� .�/�/7/f1J'i/v _.�.�._..�•�
. \�
•• �tZ�/ '_'
_ , a;�SZ�6S„69N f
, 7�o'�w_l3�f1� /f_L��lf 0?f�f �YO$/Y� N�l�/�(/, ` . � .
. „�,,
� �" � � � �! � � i
. ;
A. : ,
,
.,�� � �
� � �, C� � �����
;
� ��
:
�
z� � w �`�s
:
; � I er��:� �, � �� � ..�� ;4 s .� t�...���'
;
F
� � � � � �
,
+� � Q � S ��
� c..�.� � t 1 S
;
,
_ � � C�l)�...I-� �n C�, �►�� �ic��ac� ;
;
;
;
; � ,�._ �,
,� r`c.� 1�. �.};C..�,,,. �c�t,:a t�...
;
,
. r
� �• ��, -�
� vws � � C�►c.` � v ���...
i �
: Cra �`
3 �� C��l� � �,p rc�
� , � �
; � . �
� � �
r � ��
i .��� �1
# n� ��U�3
�---------___�..�
ti �� � JV��
' � .
1 = �L►� �1
� �
,
$ � (�c�.,�! �1'lrtfa;;.,{..i
�
.
�
; _._.. .._--�.__.�_�___... _
; _
; _ .. . � ����,� _
• 1 • P O BC�X 510
��Zl� � 2875-145TH ST. W
0���^��'� ROSEMOIJNT.MINNESOT�I 55f1GH
l,/ fit 2-4?_3-4411
AFFIDAVIT OF MAILED AND POSTED HEARING NQTICE
Craig & dolie Siemers - Zoning Appeat
STATE OF MiNNESOTA )
COUNTY (?F DAKOTA )ss
CITY OF ROSEMOUNT )
Stephan Jilk, being first duly sworn, deposes and says:
I am a United States citizen and the dnly qualified Clerk of the
�ity of Rosemounf, Minnesota:
On November 5, 1988, acting on behalf of the said City, I posted
at the City Hall, 2875 145th Street West, and deposited in the
United States Past Offiee, Rosemount, Minnesata, a copy of the
attached natice of a pnhlic hearing for the Craig and Julie
Siemers zoning appeaf regardin�; denial of a requ�st for a building
permit for an aecessory strueture, enctosed in seated envelopes,
with postage thereon fully prepaid, addressed to the persons
listed on the attaehed listings at t6e addresses listed with their
names.
There is delivery service by United States Mail between the place
of mailing and the places so addressed.
,
_
S eph` Jilk
Aclministrator/Cle
. ' City of Rosemount
Dakota County, Minnesota
Subscribed and sworn tc� hefore me this Sth day of November,
1988.
,
--_
Not y Put�lic
p!�
. ��� � � • I��a ier�Y �,i�,
��y� � �;t�l, f) . :cz.�, �r,n� ;� r
sy, „ ^it��' �� (2�1�,[MOt It!t k41t1f11 ':�ti n .'.�,�.�c
�rY �.,os�rnou.n:� ,,,; ,,; , ,,,,,,
Pubiic Notice
Tf) Wi#OM [T MAY Ct)NGERN:
NOTiCE IS ftEREBY GtVEN, the Ci[y Cpuncil ot the c��y c�f
RosemounE will hc�ld a E'uhlic F�earing �n Tuesday, Nc�vemhcr 15,
1988 in the C�uncil Chambe:rs c�f the Ciiy ii�lt, 2fi75 1qSth Slreet
West, l�eginning at R:t)() p.m. Tkc purr«sc of (�iis hcarinR is 1�
reccive cc�mments on thc 7.�niE�� i1��cat oi ('r�i� and Julie
Siemers, 14975 dallara At�cntrc, in rc��rc1 lo cicni.�) «t' a huilcling
permiE [or � 2,4(�0 sc�t�arc fnot aceec�ory hoitclinR r�n Ihe grouncls
that the prc�posecl ��se of thc huildin�; firr stnr��c commcrcially
Icased trucks is not a permi�trci usc in thc Agricultarc T�istrict.
The pro�erty in quesNc�n is tegatly elescribed as fc�ll��vs;
The s�uiM 32R.t)9 (cet c�f tbc i���rt1� 3y4.O�) fecl �f ihe
west hatf r�f thc n�►rthc;i�t Quartrr t�f �cclifin 22,
Townshi}� l]5, Rangc 19, bakc>ta Ct�unty, l�tinncsota.
Containing 1t1.�0 acres. Si�l,jcct t� ali eascnients �(
record.
Such nersc�ns as desirc t�n be l�c:�rcl willi refercncc tc� the abcwe
item wiU #�e heard at this mceting.
Dated this lst day of Novembcr, 1�8f�.
?���
Slerh�n ilk, Admini �ator/Gterk
� � � � C'ity of Rosemc�unt �
Dakota Co�rnty, Minnesota
. � r �IEMERS - ZQNING APPEAL - M:�ING LIST
1. Matilda Swaason
1dSI 133th Street East
Rosemount, MN 5506$
2. Arthwr McMenomy
2204 Dayton Avenue
St. Paul, MN 55104
3. Ronald & Margaret Andersan
1351 135th Street East
. Rosemount, MN 55068
4. Louis & June Damiani
12232 Akron Avenue
Rosemount, MN 55068
5. Richard Jr. & Dixie Cliff
1252� Akron AvenUe
Rosemount, MN 55068