HomeMy WebLinkAbout6.a. Supporting Clean Cars MN
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Environment & Sustainability Commission Meeting: February 16, 2021
AGENDA SECTION:
AGENDA ITEM: Supporting Clean Cars MN
New Business
PREPARED BY: Jane Byron, Stormwater Specialist AGENDA NO. 6.a.
ATTACHMENTS: Clean Cars MN Factsheet APPROVED BY: BLE
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Discussion
DISCUSSION:
The State of Minnesota is currently going through the Clean Cars Minnesota rulemaking. Clean Cars MN
seeks to ensure that Minnesotans continue to have access to Low Emission Vehicles and more access to
Zero Emission Vehicles in an effort to reduce greenhouse gas emissions due to their impact on climate
change. The rulemaking is currently accepting comments through March 15. The purpose of the
discussion is to decide whether the ESC would like to recommend support for and comment on the Clean
Cars MN rulemaking. More about the program can be viewed on the Clean Cars MN engagement website
https://www.pca.state.mn.us/air/clean-cars-mn and rulemaking website
https://www.pca.state.mn.us/air/clean-cars-mn-rulemaking.
SUMMARY:
No action required.
C:\\Users\\jab\\AppData\\Local\\Temp\\6.a. Supporting Clean Cars MN_635121\\6.a. Supporting Clean Cars MN.docx
Vehicle emissions standards 101
All cars, trucks, and SUVs that have an internal combustion engine produce some amount of tailpipe pollution.
Emissions standards set pollution limits to protect our health and the environment, and can also lead to improved
fuel efficiency.
As our federal government has pushed for cleaner cars, the auto industry has responded by investing in innovation
and creating cleaner, more efficient models to meet more stringent emissions standards. Drivers benefit from
saving money at the pump, and we all benefit from cleaner air to breathe and a better climate.
Clean Cars Minnesota rule
The MPCA is proposing to adopt clean cars standards to reduce greenhouse
gas (GHG) emissions and increase electric vehicles (EVs) in Minnesota.
clean cars mn
How the clean cars standards work
The Low Emission Vehicle (LEV) standard sets limits for
GHG emissions and other harmful air pollution for new
light- and medium-duty vehicles.
The LEV standard sets tailpipe emissions standards for
auto manufacturers to achieve—standards they have
been meeting successfully since 2012. It doesn’t affect
used vehicles or require emissions testing.
Adopting the LEV standard now would require auto
manufacturers to continue producing cleaner, more
efficient passenger vehicles and to continue delivering
those models for sale here in Minnesota.
The Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) standard works
differently. This standard requires auto manufacturers
to deliver more zero emissions vehicles, like battery
electric vehicles (BEVs) and plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) for
sale in Minnesota, increasing each year.
Did you know: Since 2012, all of the new cars,
trucks, and SUVs on the lot in Minnesota have met
the LEV standard.
How is that possible, if Minnesota hasn’t adopted the
LEV standard yet?
From 2012 until 2020, the federal standard and the
LEV standard were the same. So if you purchased a
new vehicle anywhere in the U.S. in the last 8 years,
you’re already benefiting from a cleaner, more fuel-
efficient vehicle that meets the LEV standard.
The standards matched until 2020, when the U.S.
EPA moved to roll back the federal GHG emissions
standards.
LEVs are already here
aq-rule4-10u
Why we should adopt the Clean Cars Minnesota rule
Taking action for a better climate
Minnesota has a goal of reducing GHG
emissions by 80% by 2050, but we’re not
on track to meet our goal. Ensuring that
Minnesotans have access to the cleanest cars
available is a practical strategy that will help
Minnesota move in the right direction.
As more older, higher-emitting vehicles
are replaced by cleaner LEV-certified
vehicles, BEVs, and PHEVs each year,
the emissions reductions will increase.
Minnesota will see cleaner air and more
climate benefits over time.
Figure 1: Annual well-to-wheel GHG emissions reductions,
beginning with model year 2025
2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034
-1.6
-1.4
-1.2
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
-0.0
CO2e emissions reduced (million tons)Key fact: In the first 10 years of implementation,
the Clean Cars Minnesota rule would reduce GHG
emissions by 8.4 million tons.
Benefits for consumers
Cost savings
Minnesotans who purchase a new LEV-certified vehicle can expect to save money at the pump because LEV-certified
cars, trucks and SUVs are more efficient. Since EVs have reduced fuel and maintenance costs compared to vehicles
with internal combustion engines, Minnesotans who purchase a new EV would also see cost benefits.
More consumer choice for EVs
There are more makes and models of EVs available in states that have adopted the ZEV standard than we can easily
acquire here. Minnesotans should have access to the new electric SUVs, cars, and pickups entering the market. EVs
currently make up less than 1% of new cars on the lot in the Twin Cities metro area (and less than 0.3% in Greater
Minnesota)—that’s not a lot of choices for consumers to consider. More new EVs on the market here could lead to
more used EVs becoming available for consumers, too.
Most popular models still available
In 2019, Minnesota’s top-selling vehicle was the Chevrolet Silverado. In every state that has adopted clean car
standards so far—California is the sole exception—the most popular vehicle is either a pickup truck or an SUV,
indicating that dealers continue to sell these vehicles and their availability has not been affected.
Learn more about GHG emissions
reductions (pages 77-78) and
other parts of MPCA’s analysis
in our Statement of need and
reasonableness (SONAR). All
page numbers refer to the
SONAR, available on the Clean
Cars rulemaking webpage.
Pages 70–75
Pages 47–50
Page 41
Supporting healthy communities
Reduces other harmful air pollution from vehicles
In the first 10 years of implementation, MPCA estimates the Clean Cars Minnesota rule would reduce 6,000+ tons
of non-methane organic gases and nitrogen oxides, and 3,000+ tons of particle pollution.
Protects our health
MPCA analysis indicates that implementing the Clean Cars
Minnesota rule could prevent between 62-348 premature deaths
from the respiratory and cardiovascular health effects of air
pollution in the first 10 years of implementation. Emergency
room visits, hospital admissions, non-fatal heart attacks, acute
bronchitis, respiratory symptoms, asthma, and work-loss days
could also be reduced.
Supports environmental justice
Lower income communities and communities of color in Minnesota are disproportionately exposed to air pollution
from vehicles. Overburdened communities would experience the greatest air quality benefits from the Clean Cars
Minnesota rule and reduced vehicle emissions.
Timeline for implementing clean car standards
If MPCA completes this rulemaking in 2021, implementation would not begin until 2024 (vehicle model year 2025).
Clean Cars MN rulemaking
finishes in 2021
Federally required
two-year waiting period
(Jan. 1, 2022 – Dec. 31, 2023)
Model year 2025 is first
possible model year affected
by Clean Cards MN rule
2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Jan. 1, 2024
Earliest date Clean Cars MN
rule could take effect
For more information
Web: mn.gov/cleancars
Email: cleancarsmn.pca@state.mn.us
Key fact: The economic value
of these avoided health
impacts is an estimated $560
million–$3.2 billion.
Pages 79–91